Judge Says No to Defunding Planned Parenthood

Print Share on LinkedIn More

June 25, 2011; Source: Indianapolis Star | A U.S. District Court judge on Friday issued a preliminary injunction against an Indiana law that prevented Planned Parenthood from serving Medicaid patients in the state.  The law, which stripped Planned Parenthood of all funding, including Medicaid reimbursements, effectively barred some 9,300 low-income individuals from access to birth control, breast exams, Pap tests and other medical services. After Judge Tanya Walton Pratt made her ruling, Betty Cokrum, president of Planned Parenthood of Indiana, said she was both "delighted and relieved" and added the group's clinics would once again be open to "Medicaid patients across the state." The anti-abortion group, Indiana Right to Life, which had lobbied for passage of the law to defund Planned Parenthood, described the court decision as going "against the will of the Indiana legislature." The judge's injunction only places a temporary hold on the law.  Planned Parenthood will now try to convince the judge to throw out the law while the state will argue that it should be allowed to stand. The judge's decision also grants another sort of reprieve to Planned Parenthood. The loss of Medicaid funding might have forced Planned Parenthood to close 28 of its health centers.  The Republican-led legislature had billed the law as an anti-abortion move, siding with those who claimed public funds were subsidizing abortions.  However, according to the Indianapolis Star, the judge wrote in her ruling that there was "no evidence of 'inappropriate commingling' of private funds used for abortion with Medicaid funds used for birth control, tests for sexually transmitted diseases and cancer screenings."—Bruce S. Trachtenberg



  • Kevin

    Strange that the point of a federal court is to rule “against the will of the…legislature” when the will of the legislature votes against the rights of people.

    Right to Life acts as though PP is an abortion factory or something equally absurd. They could easily partner with PP to ensure contraception and family planning to lower the abortion rates instead of fighting to have those preventative measures barred.

    Logic and compassion win the day.