Nonprofits as Society’s Watchdogs: Six Recent Examples

Print Share on LinkedIn More

August 19, 2011| EncTODAY | In much of the public discourse about nonprofits, it seems like the primary value attached to nonprofits is in their role as human-service providers. These safety-net nonprofits are have become focal points for issues such as the impact of reduced public funding.

But some nonprofit functions are typically not covered by government contracts and grants, and unfortunately they are also undervalued by charitable and philanthropic donors. One in particular is the “watchdog” function: the process of studying, exposing and critiquing misbehavior in government and business circles (and sometimes in nonprofit circles as well).

Yesterday, NPQ Newswire relied on the diligent investigative work of NC Policy Watch to reveal the shady nonprofit operations of a state legislator who ran two government-funded nonprofits as personal fiefdoms. Here are five more examples of nonprofits serving as watchdogs that have emerged in just the last week:

  • The Montana Policy Institute is suing the State of Montana for release of information about state employee pay records.
  • Californians Aware isn’t letting the St. Helena City Council off the hook for its repeated alleged violations of the state’s open meetings law.
  • The Wisconsin Democracy Campaign reports that in the nine recent state Senate recall elections held in Wisconsin, candidates and special interests spent between $35 and $40 million, the equivalent of $45 to $52 for each of the 769,000 votes cast.
  • California Common Sense at Stanford University just released a study showing that California Assembly members spend taxpayer money at levels far in excess of the amounts specified in their official office budgets.
  • At the federal level, the always-excellent Project on Government Oversight (POGO) was recently able to prompt a Defense Department Inspector General’s audit of the contracting process used by the Pentagon’s Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency.

These are critically important public services, providing information to voters that governments and businesses are generally reluctant to reveal unless prodded, poked, embarrassed, or sued. The reports these groups issue aren’t stupid or inconsequential. But one can be assured that their actions are routinely condemned as “political vendettas” by the political and corporate targets of their investigations, even though these nonprofit watchdogs are all nonpartisan.

Nonprofit and foundation leaders might want to remember to support and promote the watchdog function of the nonprofit sector, even if sometimes their influential friends and funders are targets. The existence of nonprofit watchdogs strengthens American democracy.—Rick Cohen

  • Terry Francke

    Thanks for the mention of Californians Aware, Rick. Litigation is only one of our methods to improve transparency and citizen involvement in local and state government. We also coach development of voluntarily adopted sunshine ordinances; sponsor and support open government legislation; conduct surveys to check compliance with sunshine laws; publish legal and practical guidebooks for citizens, officials and journalists; and answer questions about the law via phone, email and our message board. We’ve been looking for foundation support for this work, but it’s very scarce so far.

  • Lori Duboys

    NASGA was formed by victims – and their families – of unlawful and abusive guardianships and conservatorships in courts across the country. We are seeking Congressional intervention to protect due process, civil and human rights of the vulnerable elderly and disabled.

  • Ryan Sdano

    As a liberal citizen of faith. I am glad to see 6 nonprofit groups keeping track of not only government abuses but also campaign contributions & their donors during the elections. More people need to be aware of what groups & donors are giving more to during the elections. Although personally, I think all the cash spent on every election cycle is appalling, when much of that money could be used for our infrastructure, like the public schools, crumbling bridges & highways, to preserve our social safety net, clean up our environment, & expand employment.

    Keep up the good work in keeping track of all the campaign donations & government abuses.