This article is the fourth in a series of articles published by NPQ, in partnership with the First Nations Development Institute (First Nations), that lift up Native American voices to highlight issues concerning environmental justice in Indian Country and identify ways that philanthropy might more effectively support this work.
There are many lessons to be learned from indigenous aquaculture practices, especially in the areas of climate mitigation, adaptation, resilience, resource management, and food sovereignty. Today, Native Hawaiians are working to reclaim physical spaces, improve resilience, and resurface indigenous ways of knowing, observing, managing, and thriving in the Hawaiian island environment, drawing on practices that have been developed over many centuries.
“Fishponds, loko iʻa, were things that beautified the land, and a land with many fishponds was called ‘fat’ land (ʻāina momona).”
Samuel Kamakau, Na Hana a ka Poʻe Kahiko, The Works of the People of Old
One of the most isolated archipelagos on the planet, Hawaiʻi is about 2,500 miles away from any other place in the world. As the landscape’s spirit and history of our community are revived, so are the insightful and innovative practices of our Native Hawaiian ancestors. This knowledge, the lessons learned, and the people who practice them are stories of inspiration for our greater community and the global movement of indigenous people and local communities of which they are a part.
Hawaiʻi is home to some of the first known aquaculture practices in the Pacific. Loko iʻa (fishponds) are an advanced, extensive form of aquaculture found nowhere else in the world. While techniques of herding or trapping adult fish in shallow tidal areas, in estuaries, and along their inland migration can be found around the globe, Hawaiians developed loko iʻa that are technologically unique, advancing the cultivation practice of mahi iʻa (fish farmer). They exist as part of the traditional Native Hawaiian infrastructure for biocultural (integrated natural and cultural) resource abundance or ‘āina momona (literally translates as “fat lands”). ‘Āina momona stretch across and uplift the ecological and cultural functioning of the entire watershed, from mountaintop to nearshore. As Native Hawaiian historian Samuel M. Kamakau described, the existence of a loko iʻa within a functioning ecosystem or landscape alone indicates abundance.
Hawaiʻi’s traditional biocultural system for natural resource management once supported close to a million people—almost as many people as inhabit our state today—who relied entirely on island resources for survival. In this, loko iʻa served a sophisticated and essential role in protein production, producing an estimated 300 pounds of fish per acre per year. Statewide surveys identified 488 loko iʻa on six of the main Hawaiian islands.
Hawaiian innovation is reflected in the variety of loko iʻa design and construction methods, demonstrating an unparalleled understanding of engineering, hydrology, ecology, biology, and agriculture managed holistically within watershed-scale land divisions called ahupuaʻa.
In the 19th and 20th centuries, globalization and advancements in refrigeration and transportation transformed food production, and thus environmental stewardship practices globally. In Hawaiʻi, these forces, population loss from introduced diseases, and rapid socio-political change–including the overthrow of the Hawaiian government by American plantation owners–drove dramatic changes to every aspect of Hawaiian life, including loko iʻa.
Hawaiʻi’s famed/infamous history of ranching, pineapple/sugar plantation agriculture, American military land use, and rapid urban development have decimated the infrastructure of a biocultural system that once functioned sustainably across watersheds, from our mountain tops and down to the sea. The loss of Native land tenure has resulted in alienation from traditional stewardship practices like loko iʻa, limits to access land, distancing of communities from decision-making and civic engagement around natural resources, and rapid loss of knowledge and traditional practices of caring for these resources. Today, we suffer the predictable consequences of these circumstances.
The abundance of natural resources has declined severely in the last 200 years. By some estimates, production from our fisheries and agriculture in native crops like taro has fallen by as much as 90 percent. Ironically, an estimated 85-to-90 percent of the food eaten in Hawai‘i comes in on a ship or barge. Our loko iʻa too are highly degraded. Some are completely covered and unrecognizable, while very few are utilized for food today. Yet reliance on natural resources endures in rural Hawaiian communities as a tradition that feeds families, creates a strong sense of a unified community, and binds together the social elements necessary for cultural perpetuation.
Environmental justice speaks to the protection of people from environmental harms—and access to environmental goods—regardless of race, income, or color, and the equitable access to decision-making around environmental health and well-being. The ability of indigenous communities around the globe to determine our destiny, our relationship to the water, land, and living things that sustains us — thus beats the ethic and very heart of environmental justice.
The 1970s and ’80s saw a broad resurgence of a multi-ethnic and Native Hawaiian-led movement—known as the Hawaiian Renaissance—to reassert systems of Native Hawaiian language, health practices, and food production, including loko iʻa practice. This movement continues to grow.
Today rural and Native Hawaiian communities are building a movement to restore loko iʻa and their surrounding near-shore environments (fisheries, coral, and seaweed beds), and remain steadfast in the knowledge that loko iʻa maintain the potential to contribute to healthy and robust food and ecological systems. Loko iʻa revitalization continues to move hand-in-hand with the revitalization of Hawaiian language, arts, architecture, and diet. Native Hawaiian values, knowledge, and practices around stewardship, management, care, and utility of our natural resources are becoming ever more important to how conservation and business is done in Hawaiʻi.
Restoration of loko iʻa commonly targets other related issues of concern in our communities, ranging from community-based economic development to healing substance abuse. These efforts all stem from a common cultural ethic—epitomized in the Hawaiian word lōkahi (unity, harmony)—that holds that the health of people, culture, and place are all deeply entwined. We have seen that the revitalizing work of loko iʻa restores our human communities, as well as our broader interwoven community of native and endangered plants, invertebrates, fishes, and birds.
“It was so beautiful for me to create and clean something and make it beautiful. My whole life, I’ve just destroyed things. It was just such a privilege to make something beautiful. Thank you for waking me up and helping me connect to my Hawaiian culture. I thought it was too late already. I thought my kūpuna (elders) had died and left me. I know now, my kūpuna are here. There are in me. I felt them today.”—Reflection from a patient at a substance abuse treatment center on working around loko iʻa on Mokauea Island, Keʻehi.
The stewardship efforts of our communities to restore loko iʻa, local food production and manage our natural resources—healing our relationship to our places, ourselves, and each other—continue to face contemporary challenges that are complex and systemic.
Generations of severed familial and community ties to land have decimated the availability and perpetuation of precious traditional ecological knowledge for environmental stewardship and food production in our communities. What remains is highly vulnerable to loss, especially as our elder knowledge-holders age. The funding mechanisms to support these community groups are also vulnerable to reliance on well-intentioned intermediaries and funders who often have a limited time period or alignment to support the community’s work. Existing local, state, and federal policies, institutions, and programs—generally designed from a western, hierarchical paradigm of resource management—are often ill-suited to address the needs and demands of community-based stewardship practice and revival.
“One person standing alone has only one voice…it’s not as strong as 100 people standing together.”—Damien Kenison of Hoʻokena, speaking to the power of networks.
The formation of networks of Native fishers, farmers, families, and allies is a natural and powerful response to systemic and complex contemporary barriers. The formation of community-organized networks accelerated during the Hawaiian Renaissance and continues to today. Kuaʻāina Ulu ʻAuamo (KUA) is a Native Hawaiian-led organization that serves as a facilitator of “networked work.” The name means “grassroots growing through shared responsibility.” The acronym KUA means “back.” After 10 years of stewarding this work, KUA was incorporated as a nonprofit in 2013 at the request of fishers, farmers, and community leaders from over 30 rural Hawaiian communities. In strategic planning meetings, these leaders affirmed each community’s mandate to advance place-based natural resource stewardship and that systemic barriers facing our communities can best be tackled collectively.
“The word konohiki means to invite ability [and] willingness. This refers to the ability of a konohiki to organize people for collective endeavors no one family could achieve alone, such as maintenance of irrigation systems to sustain taro patches or surround net harvests.”—Carlos Andrade, Hāʻena: Through the Eyes of the Ancestors, 2008
More broadly, KUA honors the practice of konohiki in communities across our islands. Throughout Hawaiʻi today, grassroots groups and families continue to care for their places with Native Hawaiian values, culture and intelligence. Through place-based restoration and stewardship rooted in indigenous science, practice, and a worldview inherently tied to ʻāina (land, earth, literally “that which feeds”), these efforts to care for our island home have meaningful and immediate ecological and social impact on the people and storied places of Hawaiʻi.
In the face of many challenges, community self-determination and affirmation of our generational ties to land, indigenous identity and to each other are the gravitational pull that turns the tide.
KUA’s primary work is to coordinate the people and physical resources needed to create resonance for conversations within and between the networks we facilitate. The Hui Mālama Loko Iʻa is one such network, made up of over 60 sites and a growing community of over 100 kiaʻi loko (fishpond guardians and caretakers).
In February 2020, 170 kiaʻi loko and other indigenous aquaculture leaders from around the Pacific convened in a historic gathering in Heʻeia, Oʻahu, for a 4-day indigenous aquaculture summit and cultural exchange. The gathering was hosted and led by community organizations Paepae o Heʻeia and Kākoʻo ʻŌiwi, with logistical, facilitation and funding support from KUA and Hawaiʻi Sea Grant. Participants engaged in discussions, skills exchange, field trips to various other loko iʻa across Oʻahu and included a collective work project to restore 120 feet of kuapā (wall infrastructure) at Heʻeia fishpond.
This gathering provided opportunities for Hawaiʻi practitioners to share about loko iʻa practices and wahi pana (storied places) and builds on a partnership between Hawaiʻi and Washington Sea Grant programs that will eventually support an indigenous aquacultural exchange in the Pacific Northwest in 2021.
The indigenous aquaculture summit was held ahead of the Aquaculture America 2020 meeting in Honolulu, one of the largest aquaculture trade shows in the world. The conference theme: Hawaiʻi Aquaculture: A Tradition of Navigating with Innovation, Technology and Culture, was highlighted by plenary speaker Keliʻi Kotubetey who is the Assistant Executive Director at Paepae o Heʻeia.
“We build upon generations of knowledge that help inform our practice in today’s changing environment and economy,” said Kotubetey, during the indigenous summit at Heʻeia. “Our kūpuna were experts in areas of climate mitigation, adaptation, resilience, resource management, and food sovereignty. We are excited to share this with the broader community.”
Loko iʻa practice reflects a deep indigenous understanding of the environmental, ecological and social processes specific to our islands. In addition to today’s work of reclaiming physical spaces, our collective work is to also reclaim the innovation and resilience inherent to our indigenous ways of knowing, observing, managing, and thriving in our environment. The work of the Hui Mālama Loko Iʻa gives voice to some of Hawaiʻi’s most skilled and committed natural resource managers in using, sharing, and practicing traditional approaches to resource management to meet modern challenges and restore some of Hawaiʻi’s most cherished places.
As we look to the future, we envision a revival of the famed abundance of loko iʻa, while also contributing to a broader movement to reclaim Native intelligence and innovation in our land and food systems. Today loko iʻa serve as important kīpuka—which literally means oasis, but figuratively means receptacle—for the renewal of traditional practices and values in contemporary ways, but the work of loko iʻa caretakers (and many other Hawaiian subsistence practitioners) is systemically under-resourced, under-valued, and overlooked.
The restoration of loko iʻa provides inspiration for Native Hawaiians and the larger community to renew ʻāina momona, an abundant, productive ecological system that supports community well-being. The bigger need— and opportunity— is great: to grow and strengthen the social and cultural infrastructure supporting traditional ecological knowledge and the capacity of indigenous practitioners to share, teach, and perpetuate their work.
Kuaʻāina Ulu ʻAuamo means “grassroots growing through shared responsibility.” KUA the acronym means “back.” We believe that empowered community stewardship efforts lead to our vision of an abundant, productive ecological system that supports community well-being—ʻĀINA MOMONA.