logo logo
Donate
    • Membership
    • Donate
  • Social Justice
    • Racial Justice
    • Climate Justice
    • Disability Justice
    • Economic Justice
    • Health Justice
    • Immigration
    • LGBTQ+
  • Civic News
  • Nonprofit Leadership
    • Board Governance
    • Equity-Centered Management
    • Finances
    • Fundraising
    • Human Resources
    • Organizational Culture
    • Philanthropy
    • Power Dynamics
    • Strategic Planning
    • Technology
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Leading Edge Membership
  • Newsletters
  • Webinars

Will Pittsburgh Nonprofits Move Away from Overwhelmingly White Leadership?

Steve Dubb
July 31, 2018

July 25, 2018; Public Source

Earlier this year, NPQ reported on a study by the Pittsburgh-based Bayer Center for Nonprofit Management at Robert Morris University. The study, titled What Now: How will the impending retirement of nonprofit leaders change the sector?, examined succession challenges for the nonprofit sector in a community where the average executive director age is 57. Of the 195 nonprofit executives and professionals that the study surveyed, 89 percent were white. By contrast, census data reveal that city residents are roughly 64 percent white, 24 percent Black, six percent Asian, three percent Latinx, and three percent mixed race or American Indian.

This contrast raises an obvious question: Might Pittsburgh nonprofits be able to take advantage of generational change to achieve greater racial equity in leadership? This question, writes Madeleine Davison in Public Source, was the central theme of a gathering of roughly 100 Pittsburgh nonprofit representatives organized by the Program to Aid Citizen Enterprise (PACE).

To facilitate the discussion, PACE brought in Building Movement Project co-directors Sean Thomas-Breitfeld and Frances Kunreuther, coauthors of Race to Lead: Confronting the Racial Leadership Gap, a study that surveyed over 4,000 nonprofit professionals nationally that NPQ’s Cyndi Suarez covered last month. In their study, as Suarez summarized, three key findings were:

  1. Executive recruiters are not equipped to identify potential candidates of color for top-level nonprofit positions.
  2. Boards are predominantly white and often do not support the leadership of staff of color.
  3. Nebulous concepts like “fit” are great hiding places for implicit bias.

As Davison details, however, the Pittsburgh event went beyond the national findings, as participants sought to understand how the Pittsburgh community might challenge the racial bias that persists in the sector.

This included sharing stories. For example, Davison retells the story of Walter Smith Jr., who in 1997 became the first black executive director of Family Resources, a nonprofit that helps children who have suffered from child abuse and provides counseling for families. As Davison explains:

On his first fundraising mission, Smith––a licensed psychologist with a Ph.D.––had a meeting with a “very formal, well-educated” foundation director. He introduced himself to the man, who looked at him and asked a question Smith said he will never forget.

“Who are you?”

Smith said this experience “took [him] back quite a ways.”

Sign up for our free newsletters

Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

“I remember sort of stuttering my way through that. The question wasn’t like, ‘Tell me about Family Resources.’ It wasn’t, you know, ‘Tell me about your organization. Tell me about your request.’ The first question was, who am I?” Smith said. “And so it became…a question about my social role, my identity.”

Smith ended up serving as the nonprofit’s executive director for 15 years. Still, he said that he felt constant pressure to be “twice better” than his colleagues.

Fred Brown, president and CEO of The Forbes Funds, said that earlier in his career he regularly faced the challenges of whether he would be a “good fit.”

“With the ‘good fit’ statement, I get this all the time—‘You’re assertive, you’re direct, you’re intense,’” Brown said. “That’s another word, to me, to be like, ‘You’re aggressive and scary.’”

He said that if he has a passionate demeanor, there are reasons for it. “I’ve had to bury my son’s friends—my son’s 12- and 14-year-old classmates. And I had to explain to my kids at 10 and 11, and 12 and 14, how to conduct [themselves] when they see the police.… And so, I am a little bit more intense.”

“It’s interesting for us as a sector that is committed to and invested in social change…to then contend with the ways that, inside of nonprofit organizations, we replicate the same systems that are creating inequality in other parts of our lives,” Brown noted.

Sharon Jefferson, a program manager for PACE, said that one advantage of having a more diverse leadership base is that it helps nonprofits promote “trust and believability” among the communities of color they serve. In terms of tactics for promoting racial equity in the sector, Jefferson added that the way nonprofits market job openings matters. According to Jefferson, phrases in PACE’s posting such as “people of color,” “protected classes,” “fighting discrimination” and “minority youth” encouraged her to apply for the job she now holds.

At the forum, Brown also mentioned that as executive director of Homewood Children’s Village, he made explicit efforts to frequent Latinx, LGBTQ-focused, and Afrocentric events to help him build a team that reflected the community’s full diversity, both in terms of thinking and backgrounds.

Will Pittsburgh nonprofits act to foster leadership that reflects the city’s diverse population? Peggy Outon, who authored the succession study, said she sees the chance to “open up space and opportunity” for a new generation of leaders. Michelle Pagano Heck, who leads Pittsburgh-based executive search and development firm Nonprofit Talent, responded similarly: “The good news [about the coming generational shift] is that it’s busting open leadership opportunities.”

This is all well and good, but the question remains: Is Pittsburgh’s nonprofit sector capable of seizing the day?—Steve Dubb

About the author
Steve Dubb

Steve Dubb is senior editor of economic justice at NPQ, where he writes articles (including NPQ’s Economy Remix column), moderates Remaking the Economy webinars, and works to cultivate voices from the field and help them reach a broader audience. In particular, he is always looking for stories that illustrate ways to build a more just economy—whether from the labor movement or from cooperatives and other forms of solidarity economy organizing—as well as articles that offer thoughtful and incisive critiques of capitalism. Prior to coming to NPQ in 2017, Steve worked with cooperatives and nonprofits for over two decades, including twelve years at The Democracy Collaborative and three years as executive director of NASCO (North American Students of Cooperation). In his work, Steve has authored, co-authored, and edited numerous reports; participated in and facilitated learning cohorts; designed community building strategies; and helped build the field of community wealth building. Most recently, Steve coedited (with Raymond Foxworth) Invisible No More: Voices from Native America (Island Press, 2023). Steve is also the lead author of Building Wealth: The Asset-Based Approach to Solving Social and Economic Problems (Aspen 2005) and coauthor (with Rita Hodges) of The Road Half Traveled: University Engagement at a Crossroads, published by MSU Press in 2012. In 2016, Steve curated and authored Conversations on Community Wealth Building, a collection of interviews of community builders that Steve had conducted over the previous decade.

More about: Equity-Centered ManagementLeadershipNonprofit NewsRacial Justice

Our Voices Are Our Power.

Journalism, nonprofits, and multiracial democracy are under attack. At NPQ, we fight back by sharing stories and essential insights from nonprofit leaders and workers—and we pay every contributor.

Can you help us protect nonprofit voices?

Your support keeps truth alive when it matters most.
Every single dollar makes a difference.

Donate now
logo logo logo logo logo
See comments

You might also like
How Can the Nonprofit Field Better Support Volunteerism?
Jan Masaoka
Return to Office: What’s Happening in the Nonprofit Sector and Why?
Sydney Nicole Sweeney
Latine Community Groups Mobilize to Defend Medicaid Against Cuts
María Constanza Costa
New York and Other States Move to Fix Nonprofit Contracting Delays
Lauren Girardin
What to the Immigrant Is the Fourth of July?
Rebekah Barber
On the Front Lines: How Campus Organizing Can Inform Movements Today
Aashna Miharia

Upcoming Webinars

Group Created with Sketch.
July 24th, 2:00 pm ET

Organizing in Divided Times

The Relational Infrastructure We Need to Protect Democracy

Register
Group Created with Sketch.
September 24th-25th, 2:00 pm ET

Advanced QuickBooks for Nonprofits

Expert Guidance for Experienced QuickBooks Users

Register

    
You might also like
Volunteers work with children and collaborate to paint a playground mural at climate action event in San Francisco.
How Can the Nonprofit Field Better Support Volunteerism?
Jan Masaoka
At an office, people are at multiple workstations in rows of three people all looking at computer screens in front of them.
Return to Office: What’s Happening in the Nonprofit Sector...
Sydney Nicole Sweeney
A brown wooden sign attached to tree says, “The United States is the only developed nation where medical bankruptcies occur.”
Latine Community Groups Mobilize to Defend Medicaid Against...
María Constanza Costa

Like what you see?

Subscribe to the NPQ newsletter to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

See our newsletters

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Copyright
  • Donate
  • Editorial Policy
  • Funders
  • Submissions

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

 

Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.