Stories of Surviving Dire Poverty—in a Reddit Thread

Print Share on LinkedIn More


Cash Check

January 14, 2015; Washington Post

Max Ehrenfreund, a young blogger with the Washington Post, has compiled comments posted on a Reddit thread about how people survive in these United States while being poor, and the picture is amazing and distressing.

“The poor pay more for everything, from rolls of toilet paper to furniture. It’s not because they’re spendthrifts, either,” Ehrenfreund writes about the story painted by the Reddit posts. “If you’re denied a checking account, there’s no way for you to avoid paying a fee to cash a paycheck. If you need to buy a car to get to work, you’ll have to accept whatever higher interest rate you’re offered. If you don’t have a car, the bus fare might eat up the change you’d save shopping at a larger grocery store as opposed to the local corner store.”

According to one Reddit user, “When you are poor, the ‘system’ is set up to keep you that way.” Another wrote, “Growing up really poor means realizing in your twenties that Mommy was lying when she said she already ate.”

“I buy ‘fish’ antibiotics online because I can’t afford health care…amoxicillin and such,” yet another Reddit user wrote. “Mostly for husband who has Lyme’s disease. We can’t afford our monthly health care rates. We are 30somethings in the US. Really feel like a ‘bottom feeder.’”

Ehrenfreund references the “ghetto tax,” the economists’ concept of poor people having to pay higher costs associated with daily living. Examples include the expense of cashing checks, the higher rates of homeowner’s insurance in poor neighborhoods, higher costs associated with buying and insuring a car, the costs of installment plans for purchasing appliances, and more.

The many additional examples in Ehrenfreund’s article are simply heartwrenching. The quotes from the Reddit users sound like stories from the Great Depression, as though they were retold by James Agee and photographed by Walker Evans, but they are stories of today—in a society that purportedly has recovered from a recession, is making some people extraordinarily wealthy, and producing record stock market returns. Nonprofits know this narrative all too well, but the American public generally doesn’t. That makes Ehrenfreund’s article—and the entire Reddit thread—important reality reading.—Rick Cohen


  • Terry Fernsler

    The system is designed to keep the poor poor, more now than ever. Landlords require first, last, and deposit, meaning if you are poor and have to move, you are most likely going to have to move into worse conditions, which will put you at greater health risk. Some people used to be able to work their way out of poverty, but you hear fewer such stories today.

    The situation is not like the Great Depression, however. My parents grew up during the Depression, and their memories were of people helping each other, because so many people were in the same situation. Today we have become so polarized, and we are so economically segregated, that many middle- and upper-income people are completely unaware of the poverty conditions, or they try to get “those people” out of their city. As government assistance wanes (and, Rand Paul, the people who are really “gaming” the system are the corporate welfare cheats who pay no taxes), more families are facing conditions similar to Tsarist Russia.

  • Stormy Ron White

    Poverty is destructive to people who can find no way out, no hope, no bootstrap up. Wealth can be used either to constructively provide people with a way out or it can be used to keep them in their dire circumstances. The struggle between the two – what I would term good vs. evil – doesn’t have to be bi-polar. Research long ago affirmed that pulling together – synergy – builds better outcomes than negative competitiveness. Let’s work to educate those at the top who live in abject fear that they are going to lose their economic position. They don’t have to live in fear or be aggressive in self-protection. We can all work together to conquer society’s problems. Achieving this objective will be difficult and take time, decades probably. But, it can be done. People are good in their basic nature and will love each other given the opportunity.