logo
Donate
    • Membership
    • Donate
  • Social Justice
    • Racial Justice
    • Climate Justice
    • Disability Justice
    • Economic Justice
    • Health Justice
    • Immigration
    • LGBTQ+
  • Civic News
  • Nonprofit Leadership
    • Board Governance
    • Equity-Centered Management
    • Finances
    • Fundraising
    • Human Resources
    • Organizational Culture
    • Philanthropy
    • Power Dynamics
    • Strategic Planning
    • Technology
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Leading Edge Membership
  • Newsletters
  • Webinars

Is the Growth of Health Care Ministries a Blessing? The Problem of Inappropriate Scaling

Martin Levine
February 8, 2018
U.S. Air Force photo by Senior Airman Jonathan Hehnly.

February 4, 2018; Politico

When President Obama signed the Affordable Care Act into law, it seemed that the nation was well on the path toward making a minimum level of health care available to all Americans. But now the pendulum is swinging back to a time when medical insurance came in many shapes and forms, with little standardization or guarantee of continuing coverage.

The efforts to undermine the core principles of the ACA—required insurance and a standard level of care—have increased coverage costs, pushing many to look for more affordable options. According to Politico, this has resulted in skyrocketing enrollment in health care ministries (HCMs), “particularly in states in which the individual insurance market has been beset by spiraling premiums and dwindling competition.”

As more people look for cheaper alternatives to health insurance, they are stumbling on ministry plans to escape Obamacare’s requirements and state oversight, but still satisfy the law’s individual mandate which, despite its repeal in the recent tax overhaul, remains in effect until 2019.

Traditionally, HCMs bring together individuals within a shared religious framework who agree to cooperatively share responsibility for medical costs. Each HCM member agrees to contribute a set monthly amount, to pay up to an annual maximum amount for their health needs, and to accept the plan’s behavioral expectations. Together, the members of the HCM agree to pay any costs a member has above their annual cap.

As described in an earlier look by NPQ, nonprofit HCMs draw their inspiration from “biblically rooted principles of community” and shared responsibility for the needs of others.” Since HCMs are not insurance policies, there’s no guarantee that the whole of a bill will be paid. As one ministry member told the New York Times, “There’s a little bit of fear going into it. What if people don’t pay their share and what if the money doesn’t come in? But that’s where the faith-based part comes in—I’m really going to rely on God.”

Sign up for our free newsletters

Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

The uncertain future of the ACA, which has roiled the traditional insurance market, has proved to be beneficial to health care ministries, which now serve an estimated 1.1 million, up from 150,000 participants when the ACA became the law of the land. This growth, however, brings with it new challenges for HCM leadership.

As with many lower-cost alternatives, health care experts worry that HCMs are growing by attracting younger and healthier individuals, leaving older, sicker, and more expensive individuals for someone else to worry about. Kevin Lucia, a research professor at Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms, told Politico that “if healthy people gravitate toward these other arrangements, like health care sharing ministries, it can lead to higher premiums and less plan options for the people left behind. It can have detrimental effects on the risk pool.”

Because these are not insurance policies and fall outside the oversight of state insurance regulators, there is no oversight of how each plan manages its assets, nor any requirements for there being sufficient reserves on hand to cover projected costs. Each HCM member is taking a leap of faith that their ministry will be able to meet their needs when the bills come due. And, if they cannot or will not meet the medical needs of their members, that burden will fall to others.

The very forces that have fueled the growth of HCMs also pose a challenge to each plan’s organizers: Should they become more aggressive in the marketplace by deemphasizing their religious nature and downplaying the faith-based expectations that have been their hallmark? Some have begun to allow brokers to sell their plans and no longer require a pastor to certify the credentials of each new member.

At their best, HCMs let those with a shared belief band together to deal with the rising costs of modern health care. As long as their communities remain cohesive, they have a strong reason to exist and should be allowed to continue alongside any national health plan. But, when the allure of growth causes them to minimize this common element and become just another insurance option, there is reason to worry about continuing to allow them to operate outside the regulated health insurance system. Can they resist economic temptation? As long as the political winds continue to push away from the ACA’s shared vision, we will have a chance to find out.—Martin Levine

About the author
Martin Levine

Martin Levine is a Principal at Levine Partners LLP, a consulting group focusing on organizational change and improvement, realigning service systems to allow them to be more responsive and effective. Before that, he served as the CEO of JCC Chicago, where he was responsible for the development of new facilities in response to the changing demography of the Metropolitan Jewish Community. In addition to his JCC responsibilities, Mr. Levine served as a consultant on organizational change and improvement to school districts and community organizations. Mr. Levine has published several articles on change and has presented at numerous conferences on this subject. A native of New York City, Mr. Levine is a graduate of City College of New York (BS in Biology) and Columbia University (MSW). He has trained with the Future Search and the Deming Institute.

More about: Equity-Centered ManagementGiving CirclesHealth JusticeNonprofit NewsReligious / Faith-Based

Our Voices Are Our Power.

Journalism, nonprofits, and multiracial democracy are under attack. At NPQ, we fight back by sharing stories and essential insights from nonprofit leaders and workers—and we pay every contributor.

Can you help us protect nonprofit voices?

Your support keeps truth alive when it matters most.
Every single dollar makes a difference.

Donate now
logo logo logo logo logo
See comments

You might also like
Burnout Among the Youngest Climate Activists
Alison Stine
Learning from a Near-Death Experience: How to Survive a Budget Crisis
Donnie Maclurcan
Advocates Discuss How Best to Support the Autism Community
Matthew Rozsa
Passage of GOP Tax Bill Would Worsen Medical Debt Crisis
Rebekah Barber
Know Your Farmer: Addressing the Heart of Food Insecurity in Kensington
Iris M. Crawford
Merging Missions: Starting with Relationships and Shared Authority
Hoang Murphy

Upcoming Webinars

Group Created with Sketch.
June 26th, 2:00 pm ET

From Performance Management to Mutual Commitment

Fostering a Culture of Joyful Accountability

Register
Group Created with Sketch.
July 24th, 2:00 pm ET

Organizing in Divided Times

The Relational Infrastructure We Need to Protect Democracy

Register

    
You might also like
A young person with red hair holds up a cardboard sign that reads System Change, Not Climate Change at a protest.
Burnout Among the Youngest Climate Activists
Alison Stine
Conservatives Attack Nonprofits on Capitol Hill
Isaiah Thompson
A drawing of interlocking gears inside of two connected human heads, likely part of a mechanical system.
Learning from a Near-Death Experience: How to Survive a...
Donnie Maclurcan

Like what you see?

Subscribe to the NPQ newsletter to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

See our newsletters

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Copyright
  • Donate
  • Editorial Policy
  • Funders
  • Submissions

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

 

Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.