A struggle over who could most believably wrap him- or herself in the mantle of Martin Luther King, Jr. has been underway for some time, but the advent of the Occupy movement has brought the holiday into sharp relief. Across the Internet a week before the day there were messages, notices, and YouTube videos about “Reclaim MLK Day” actions scheduled for January 16. Here is a small sampling:

  • The January 13th “Occupations Report” issued by called for readers to host “MLK Movement Meet-ups” for activists to participate in “reflecting, and committing to rebuilding the American Dream and Dr. King’s dream in 2012.” The brief notice of the meet-up call combines two metaphors: that Martin Luther King, Jr. Day “[t]oo often . . . gets watered down into a feel-good Hallmark Card” and that “his dream is being gunned down before our eyes.”
  • A Reclaim MLK Day page on Facebook called for Occupy movement activists to gather at the African Burial Ground site in lower Manhattan to “embark on a journey to liberation, together,” citing Dr. King’s call for “an end to class stratification” and King’s notion of a Resurrection City (as expressed in his Poor People’s Campaign) “to be planted in D.C., much like the Occupy encampments across the country. . . .”.
  • The Rebuild the Dream website’s blog mentioned MLK Day Movement Meet-ups aimed at “celebrat[ing] Dr. King and link[ing] the Civil Rights Movement with today’s struggle for an economy that works for all.”. Rebuild the Dream identifies Van Jones, former clean energy advisor to President Obama and previously director of the Ella Baker Center in San Francisco as one of its presidents and co-founders.
  • The “Occupy the Dream” coalition planned a day of action aimed at “occupying” Federal Reserve Bank branches in 15 cities on January 16, based on a plan of uniting the “African-American faith community” with Occupy Wall Street “to launch a new campaign for economic justice inspired by the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.” Occupy the Dream appears to have been founded by Dr. Ben Chavis, a former executive director of the NAACP (and now president and CEO of the Hip-Hop Summit Action Network), and Rev. Dr. Jamal Bryant of Baltimore’s Empowerment Temple Church.

These calls for direct, political action aimed at inequitable economic policies are very unlike the “MLK Day of Service” campaign, part of the White House’s “United We Serve” initiative, being promoted by the Corporation for National and Community Service. The Corporation’s Day of Service video features such longtime civil rights leaders as Congressman John Lewis, Ruby Bridges, and Rev. Joseph E. Lowery who worked and marched with Dr. King. Searching for service events projects in Washington, DC registered with the official MLK Day website revealed the following:

  • Painting the AmeriCorps room and a large MLK mural at the Perry School;
  • We Feed Our People (WFOP) providing meals for the homeless;
  • Painting and light construction at Dunbar High School, the Boys and Girls Club, and Community Academy Public Charter school, sponsored by Washington, DC’s City Year;
  • The Theta Omega Omega chapter of the Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority holding a Sunday dinner at a VA hospital and inviting residents of the John McDermott House (transitional living facility for veterans discharged from the VA hospital) and residents of Fisher House (which provides temporary housing for military families while their relatives are being treated at the VA) to participate;
  • Beautification of Tyler Elementary School via school slogans, murals, and math equations;
  • Revamping the parent room at Community Academic Public Schools, hanging a portrait of Dorothy Height at the school entrance, and leading children through a reflection activity;
  • Painting and hanging murals at the Davis elementary school;
  • An MLK activity fair for children at the Burrville Elementary School, feeding the kids lunch, preparing an aquarium, and cleaning various school areas.

There are of course at least two more claimants to the King mantle. Just don’t even bother with the corporate advertisers that have run facile newspaper ads extolling their corporate connection to the values of Dr. King. More significant is the connection of the civil rights community, frequently expressed in the annual Martin Luther King, Jr. Day breakfasts and marches sponsored by local NAACP chapters around the nation. Even within the news reports of the NAACP programs, the debate between service and action is evident. For example, the theme of this year’s MLK Day breakfast of the NAACP in Cleveland, Tennessee is “Day of Service”, and in Springfield, Illinois, the NAACP MLK Day march will end at a Baptist Church, with a program titled “What Would Dr. King Say about Bullying Today?”. Contrast those traditional NAACP events with the schedule of national NAACP director Ben Todd Jealous surrounding the holiday, including his scheduled participation with U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder at an MLK Day event in South Carolina, where the theme is “preserving full citizenship rights for all Americans” (which the NAACP is using to oppose the state’s pending Voter ID law and culminating with his joining other activists in lobbying the Maryland legislature to abolish the death penalty.

The MLK Day service activities promoted by the Corporation for National and Community Service and the White House reflect a very different vision of honoring the legacy of Dr. King compared to the political activism of the various Occupy initiatives and some of the NAACP programs. Which set of events captures the spirit and legacy of Dr. King better?

King actually did take aim at problems of economic distress and inequities in our society. His concept of civil rights broadened over time from issues of race to concerns about the