logo
  • Nonprofit News
  • Management
    • Boards and Governance
    • Communication
      • Framing & Narratives
    • Ethics
    • Financial Management
    • Grassroots Fundraising Journal
    • Leadership
    • Technology
  • Philanthropy
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Donor-Advised Funds
    • Foundations
    • Impact Investing
    • Research
    • Workplace Giving
  • Policy
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Housing
    • Government
    • Taxes
  • Economic Justice
    • About
    • Economy Remix
    • Economy Webinars
    • Community Benefits
    • Economic Democracy
    • Environmental Justice
    • Fair Finance
    • Housing Rights
    • Land Justice
    • Poor People’s Rights
    • Tax Fairness
  • Racial Equity
  • Social Movements
    • Community Development
    • Community Organizing
    • Culture Change
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Gender Equality
    • Immigrant Rights
    • Indigenous Rights
    • Labor
    • LGBTQ+
    • Racial Justice
    • Youth Activism
  • About Us
  • Log in
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Featured Articles
  • Webinars
    • Free Webinars
    • Premium On-Demand Webinars
  • Tiny Spark Podcast
  • Magazine
    • Magazine
    • Leading Edge Membership
Donate
Internal Revenue Service

What’s the Likely Outcome of the IRS’s Proposed Gift Reporting Rule?

Michael Wyland
December 24, 2015
Share73
Share46
Email
Tweet
Money-envelope
Image Credit: Jake Slagle

The IRS has proposed a rule to allow a second way to permit donors to claim tax deductions for their charitable gifts which would make use of donor social security numbers. Many charity leaders are alarmed at what they see as an additional paperwork burden, and privacy advocates see danger. There is also much misinformation about the proposed regulations, mainly due to the mistaken belief that the reporting details of all gifts to the IRS will become mandatory for charities.

The IRS’s proposed rule would create an optional reporting form for charities to document to the IRS all gifts received from donors. The form, once designed, would allow charities to assume the burden of reporting all donors’ charitable gifts to the IRS as an alternative to the donor providing the required receipts. The federal web site regulations.gov provides a summary of the history and the proposed rule.

According to regulations.gov, 37,977 comments were submitted on the proposed rule during the 90-day public comment period, which closed on December 16th, 2015. A brief review of the comments submitted indicates that most commenters are strongly opposed to the proposed rule, with many referring specifically to the collection and transmission of donors’ Social Security numbers by charities. Industry organizations BoardSource and the National Council for Nonprofits (NCN) prepared articles and issued “action alerts” to members encouraging comments opposing the proposed.

The opposition isn’t surprising. Charity reporting of donor gifts hasn’t been a big issue, and the IRS itself says that “The present…system works effectively, with minimal burden on donors and donees, and the Treasury Department and the IRS have received few requests since the issuance of TD 8690 [in 1997] to implement a donee reporting system.”

Since 1994, the IRS has required taxpayers claiming deductions for charitable gifts to provide a “contemporaneous written acknowledgement” (i.e., a gift receipt) prepared by the charity and including specific information showing who gave, what was given, what (if anything) the donor may have received in exchange for the gift, and the identifying information for the charity (see IRS Publication 1771 for specifics).

Failure to have proper and complete gift receipts has caused some taxpayers’ deductions to be disallowed. NPQ reported on one Texas couple who lost the opportunity to claim just over $25,000 in gifts to their church due to incomplete receipting. The couple argued that the receipts were “substantially complete” and the church even provided complete receipting after the IRS issued its challenge. However, the U.S. Tax Court held that the receipting regulations are absolute and that the couple had to pay an additional $9,000 in taxes and penalties.

The 1994 changes included a provision for the IRS to develop rules that would allow donors to qualify for charitable gift deductions if the charity itself provided the required reporting information to the IRS. Advocates for donors whose deductions were disallowed cite the rulemaking authority and suggest that the IRS Form 990 information return that charities must file annually would satisfy the need. The IRS disagrees, saying that the Form 990’s Schedule B (where certain large gifts are reported) does not include all the information it would need to substantiate a deduction. In addition, since a charity may file an amended Form 990 years after a gift was received, the 990 reporting would lack the required “contemporaneous” element.

Designing a form for charities to file wouldn’t be difficult for the IRS. Some industry analysts have pointed to the Form 1098-C, used for reporting gifts of boats, planes, and motor vehicles, as a potential model. The challenge, according to NCN, is the potential for disclosure of donors’ Social Security numbers by charities and by the IRS. NPQ has reported about past public disclosures of private taxpayer information by the IRS. Donors concerned about the potential for hacking and identity theft may be less willing to give if charities ask for personal information, especially if they cite IRS requirements, causing a “chilling effect” on gifts.

But, the presence of a charity reporting option may also increase the legal liability for charities that issue incomplete or defective gift receipts to donors. Those donors may cite the presence of the option as a factor increasing a charity’s liability for failing to provide adequate receipting to a donor denied a deduction. Some opponents also fear that a implementing a permissive IRS option for donee reporting may eventually become a requirement for most or all charities.

There is only a remote likelihood of the IRS proceeding to a final rule and initiating design of a reporting form. The IRS doesn’t see a strong demand for the option, public comments are overwhelmingly negative about the concept, and the IRS is strapped for cash as Congress continues to punish the agency for the IRS scandal involving nonprofit organizations and the IRS’s perceived lack of cooperation and accountability in the various investigations. In addition, Sen. Pat Roberts (R-KS) has introduced legislation to prohibit the IRS from collecting Social Security numbers of charitable donors, effectively blocking the IRS-proposed initiative.

Share73
Share46
Email
Tweet

About The Author
Michael Wyland

Michael L. Wyland currently serves as an editorial advisory board member and consulting editor to The Nonprofit Quarterly, with more than 400 articles published since 2012. A partner in the consulting firm of Sumption & Wyland, he has more than thirty years of experience in corporate and government public policy, management, and administration.

Related
High-Powered Coalition Advances Plan to Reform Philanthropy
By Ruth McCambridge
December 2, 2020
What Have You Done for Me Lately? Building Healthy Relationships through e-Newsletters
By Nzinga Koné-Miller
November 20, 2020
Welcoming Your Friends’ Friends
By Nzinga Koné-Miller
November 20, 2020
Nurturing Relationships Today and for Years to Come
By Kevin Johnson
November 19, 2020
Got a Nonprofit Status Revocation Notice? Don’t Panic—The IRS Erred
By Ruth McCambridge
October 27, 2020
It’s Almost November…Has Your Tax Exemption Been Revoked?
By Ruth McCambridge
October 22, 2020

Upcoming Webinars

Group Created with Sketch.
January 21, 2 pm ET

Remaking the Economy

Health, Racial Disparities, and Economic Justice

other posts by The Author
Civil Society and the Rules of Impeachment in the Age of...
By Michael Wyland
September 25, 2019
NY and NJ File Suit to Challenge Feds on Donor Disclosure...
By Michael Wyland
May 9, 2019
Pink Ladies’ $320K Jackpot: A Charitable Game Gone Massive
By Michael Wyland
April 9, 2019
CYNDI SUAREZ
The Nonprofit Racial Leadership Gap: Flipping the Lens
Powerful Interests Seek to Make Puerto Rico the Hong Kong of the...
Moving Beyond the Privilege of White Tears
logo
Donate
  • About
  • Contact
  • Newsletters