Follow-Up: Boy Scouts Face Loss of Nonprofit Status in California

Print Share on LinkedIn More



April 10, 2013; The Sacramento Bee, “Capitol Alert”

The Nonprofit Quarterly newswire has often reported on events surrounding the Boy Scouts of America’s long-term, unilateral ban on involvement of gay scouts or scout leaders. Most recently, NPQ reported in February on a meeting of the national Board of Directors of the Scouts in which the idea of lifting the ban was to be addressed. As protesters gathered outside the meeting hall, the Board suddenly chose not to put the discussion on their agenda, saying it required additional study.

Now the Scouts are facing a new challenge. The Sacramento Bee reports that a bill has advanced in the California Senate that would repeal the tax-exempt status of any youth organization that discriminates on the basis of gender identity, sexual orientation, or religious affiliation. Senate Bill 323 has cleared the Senate Governance and Finance Committee on a party-line vote of 5-2.

Critics of the bill argue that this is unconstitutional, and that the Supreme Court has already ruled that private organizations have the right to make their own membership decisions. Supporters of the bill argue that it makes clear that the State of California will not support any organization that has discriminatory policies.—Ron Meiksins

  • noexceptions

    If the Boy Scouts of America desires a tax exempt status it must follow the rules. The organization is not above the law.

  • Bill Louree

    I am also bothered by the “religious affiliation” inclusion. Do Catholic youth groups have to include those of other faiths? Can any group be forced to accept atheists? Will Republicans have to accept Democrats? Will coed club sports teams have to include boys now?