logo
    • Magazine
    • Membership
    • Donate
  • Racial Justice
  • Economic Justice
    • Collections
  • Climate Justice
  • Health Justice
  • Leadership
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Subscribe
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Complimentary Webinars
    • Premium On-Demand Webinars
  • Membership
  • Submissions

Agua Caliente Indians Victory Could Alter Water Practices in Western States

Steve Dubb
December 6, 2017
Share
Tweet
Share
Email
Print
From WaterWired.

November 30, 2017; News Deeply, “Water Deeply”

“On Monday, November 27, the United States Supreme Court let stand a California federal appellate court decision that could chart a new course for Native American tribal groundwater rights,” reports Debra Utacia Krol in News Deeply.

The case was Agua Caliente Band v. Coachella Valley Water District. Last March, Krol reports, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that the Cahuilla’s water rights include an aquifer that lies beneath the Palm Springs-based tribe’s 31,500-acre reservation.

“The United States impliedly reserved appurtenant water sources, including groundwater, when it created the Tribe’s reservation in California’s arid Coachella Valley,” the judges ruled. 

The court’s decision is based on the Winters Doctrine, which, Krol explains, “springs from a 1908 Supreme Court decision that reserves the federal government’s right to reserve sufficient water for Indian reservations’ needs.” The decision in the Agua Caliente case effectively affirms that tribes have a federally reserved right to groundwater, at least within Ninth Circuit states. In addition to California, the Ninth Circuit includes Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon and Washington.

Krol writes that, “The Agua Caliente case was the culmination of a struggle over nearly two decades.” Four years ago, Agua Caliente filed their suit against the Coachella Valley Water District (CVWD) and the Desert Water Agency to “gain ownership and control of a portion of the aquifer.”

Sign up for our free newsletters

Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

The water levels in the 65-mile-long aquifer have fallen 55 feet over the past 40 years due to overuse. The water agencies’ solution was to direct untreated Colorado River water into the aquifer through a process that is called “artificial replenishment.”

The water districts in the Palm Springs area claim the water quality is sound. However, Agua Caliente and many other water agencies have concerns about Colorado River water quality. Krol notes that, “Some of the region’s biggest water agencies—the Central Arizona Project (CAP), the Southern Nevada Water Authority and the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California—formed the Lower Colorado River Water Quality Partnership to address issues that impact Colorado River quality, including dissolved salts, selenium, phosphorus, nitrate, pathogens, pharmaceutical and personal care products, perchlorate, chromium 6 and uranium.” In a white paper, Krol adds, “CAP officials determined that these contaminants could pose an ‘immediate or long-term threat to the river’s water quality.’”

“The case is going to be very important for any state within the Ninth Circuit,” says Judith Dworkin, an American Indian law attorney in Phoenix. Dworkin, notes Krol, has worked on American Indian water rights settlement and litigation, but has not been involved in the Agua Caliente case. Arizona, Dworkin adds, however, will feel less impact “as the Arizona Supreme Court has already determined that [an American Indian nation] may have a federal reserved right to groundwater if surface waters are inadequate to accomplish the reservation’s purposes.”

While Agua Caliente’s court victory has established its aquifer water rights, The Ninth Circuit Court still needs to hold a second trial to determine how much of the aquifer belongs to Agua Caliente. The second trial will involve so-called “Phase 2 Legal Issues—the correct standard or methodology for quantifying the tribe’s share, whether the federal reserved or Winters water right carries with it a right to water of a certain quality and whether the tribe owns the groundwater storage space, or pore space, under its reservation,” says Kate Anderson, director of public relations for Agua Caliente.

For Agua Caliente, the legal ruling allows them to “explore the range of water sources available to…[develop] a long-term plan,” says Dworkin. For water agencies, “it may require those with state water rights to establish working relationships with [American Indian nations] to develop aquifer management programs.”—Steve Dubb

Share
Tweet
Share
Email
Print
About the author
Steve Dubb

Steve Dubb is senior editor of economic justice at NPQ, where he writes articles (including NPQ’s Economy Remix column), moderates Remaking the Economy webinars, and works to cultivate voices from the field and help them reach a broader audience. Prior to coming to NPQ in 2017, Steve worked with cooperatives and nonprofits for over two decades, including twelve years at The Democracy Collaborative and three years as executive director of NASCO (North American Students of Cooperation). In his work, Steve has authored, co-authored, and edited numerous reports; participated in and facilitated learning cohorts; designed community building strategies; and helped build the field of community wealth building. Steve is the lead author of Building Wealth: The Asset-Based Approach to Solving Social and Economic Problems (Aspen 2005) and coauthor (with Rita Hodges) of The Road Half Traveled: University Engagement at a Crossroads, published by MSU Press in 2012. In 2016, Steve curated and authored Conversations on Community Wealth Building, a collection of interviews of community builders that Steve had conducted over the previous decade.

More about: Supreme CourtCalifornia Native AmericansNonprofit NewsPolicy

Become a member

Support independent journalism and knowledge creation for civil society. Become a member of Nonprofit Quarterly.

Members receive unlimited access to our archived and upcoming digital content. NPQ is the leading journal in the nonprofit sector written by social change experts. Gain access to our exclusive library of online courses led by thought leaders and educators providing contextualized information to help nonprofit practitioners make sense of changing conditions and improve infra-structure in their organizations.

Join Today
logo logo logo logo logo
See comments

Spring-2023-sidebar-subscribe
You might also like
Cancelling Student Debt Is Necessary for Racial Justice
Kitana Ananda
To Save Legal Aid, Expand Public Service Loan Forgiveness
Zoë Polk
No Justice, No Peace of Mind and Body: The Health Impacts of Housing Insecurity for Black Women
Jhumpa Bhattacharya, Maile Chand and Andrea Flynn
The Human Impact of the Global Refugee Crisis Must Be Understood—And Acted Upon
Anmol Irfan
Black Americans Need Reparations: The Fight for the CTC Highlights the Roadblocks
Jhumpa Bhattacharya and Trevor Smith
Edgar Cahn’s Second Act: Time Banking and the Return of Mutual Aid
Steve Dubb

NPQ Webinars

April 27th, 2 pm ET

Liberatory Decision-Making

How to Facilitate and Engage in Healthy Decision-making Processes

Register Now
You might also like
Cancelling Student Debt Is Necessary for Racial Justice
Kitana Ananda
To Save Legal Aid, Expand Public Service Loan Forgiveness
Zoë Polk
No Justice, No Peace of Mind and Body: The Health Impacts of...
Jhumpa Bhattacharya, Maile Chand and Andrea Flynn

Like what you see?

Subscribe to the NPQ newsletter to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

See our newsletters

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

NPQ-Spring-2023-cover

Independent & in your mailbox.

Subscribe today and get a full year of NPQ for just $59.

subscribe
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Copyright
  • Careers

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

 

Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.