logo
    • Magazine
    • Membership
    • Donate
  • Racial Justice
  • Economic Justice
    • Collections
  • Climate Justice
  • Health Justice
  • Leadership
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Subscribe
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Complimentary Webinars
    • Premium On-Demand Webinars
  • Membership
  • Submissions

Does Nonprofit Hospital Care Makes A Difference?

Rick Cohen
January 4, 2008
Share
Tweet
Share
Email
Print

The October 30 roundtable held by the minority (Republican) staff of the Senate Finance Committee (SFC) on nonprofit hospitals sparked some troubling memories.

When I was the director of a city government agency in Jersey City during the 1980s, I inherited a dynamic initiated by the preceding administration to do away with the Jersey City Medical Center (JCMC), the public hospital resource serving New Jersey’s second largest city and most populous county.

Once the largest hospital in the state, the campus of JCMC included buildings created during the Depression by boss mayor Frank “I am the law” Hague are historic art deco marvels with terra-cotta Greek and Egyptian motif carvings, eagerly eyed as high-income apartments and condominiums. (Robert Redford chose JCMC’s Murdoch Hall to stand in for Rockefeller Center for the 1993 film Quiz Show about Twenty One, the 1950s-era game show scandal). No matter what, the conversion of these architectural marvels from health to housing was going to happen. To replace JCMC, a previous administration had planned a streamlined, smaller, relocated hospital, but we had some misgivings about whether those plans were made by people who cared about the differences between nonprofit hospitals and their private-sector analogs or whether they actually knew anything at all about those issues.

My staff at the city’s Department of Housing and Economic Development was made up of tenant activists, affordable housing finance people, and community organizers. Hospitals were hardly our area of expertise, so we studied the arcane world of health care and hospital finances. I’ll never forget the shock of discovering how the city’s nonprofit hospitals, run by religious orders, treated some of the city’s poor.

I learned that the emergency room at the nonprofit hospital nearest to my Jersey City home would physically tag poor people—with a paper and safety pin—and have them sit and wait until they were picked up and transported to the public medical center. And I learned about the state’s standards for charity care or community benefit, where bad debt was community benefit. I thought of one thuggish developer in the city whose ultra-luxury development had gone bankrupt (though not before he pocketed his share) and imagined him skipping out on his hospital bills and having his savings counted as a community benefit.

The luxury real estate juggernaut won out and a shrunken, private nonprofit Jersey City Medical Center replaced Boss Hague’s complex. I vaguely remembered a recent news report about an audit of the new hospital in 2006 and the CEO bolting the day after the findings were presented to the board (though not released publicly).

One local Hudson County scandal sheet noted that the salary of the CEO at the nonprofit hospital, which served Jersey City’s low-income constituency, was $850,000—relatively low by some nonprofit hospital standards. This figure wasn’t clear from the multiple 990s that listed him in some sort of senior capacity or another, but then the 990 is hardly an edifying document, especially when organizations have multiple ways of hiding information from the public (such as paying a CEO’s salary through an external, privately held for-profit management company).

Sign up for our free newsletters

Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

Echoes of Jersey City at the SFC

Back at the Senate Finance Committee roundtable, one university-based panelist noted that some nonprofit hospital CEOs manage to hide their salaries from their own boards. Not one of the hospital representatives spoke up to contradict the guy! What’s going on here?

The hospital industry spokespeople followed the anti-regulatory script, touting what nonprofit hospitals do in charity care and community benefit, portraying themselves as kindly, though large, institutional versions of Marcus Welby, M.D. Like the exception-minded foundations that argued against higher foundation payout in 2003, the hospital industry spokespersons read from the same catechism, each one repeating “one size doesn’t fit all” as the all-purpose response to the minority staff’s working paper on nonprofit hospital regulatory issues. Hospital execs also pitched various kinds of community benefit activities as the charitable equivalent of providing health-care treatment services to underinsured and uninsured poor people.

There’s an obvious conundrum on both sides of the Senate Finance Committee debate. For the nonprofit hospitals, all too often there is little in their charity care and community benefit activities that is sharply distinguishable from their so-called for-profit competitors. The minority staff’s questions about what can and should characterize a nonprofit hospital nonprofit are legitimate.

For the minority staff promoting substantive charity care and community benefits from nonprofit hospitals, they should not permit themselves to drift into thinking that nonprofit hospital charity care can take the place of necessary government expansion of subsidized health insurance and health care. The coincidental timing of the SFC hospital roundtable on the heels of a veto by President George W. Bush of legislation to expand State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) coverage underscores the challenge. Nonprofit hospitals merit having their questionably charitable feet held to the fire, but carving out expanded nonprofit hospitals for the poor does not take the place of a comprehensive national health insurance program.

Like my staff in Jersey City two decades ago, we all have much to learn about nonprofit hospitals. We shouldn’t be blinded by the 501(c )(3) plaques on their walls such that we fail to challenge exactly how nonprofit they really are and how they deliver for society. Remember, while only 5.6 percent of registered nonprofits and just less than 9 percent of nonprofits file 990s with the IRS (5,211 out of 581,568 organizations, according to data from the Urban Institute’s National Center for Charitable Statistics), hospitals account for 17.29 percent of nonprofit filers’ assets and 24.4 percent of nonprofit revenues. Expect upcoming installments of the Cohen Report to devote increasing attention to the challenge of reminding nonprofit hospitals of their necessary “nonprofitness.”

Share
Tweet
Share
Email
Print
About the author
Rick Cohen

Rick joined NPQ in 2006, after almost eight years as the executive director of the National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP). Before that he played various roles as a community worker and advisor to others doing community work. He also worked in government. Cohen pursued investigative and analytical articles, advocated for increased philanthropic giving and access for disenfranchised constituencies, and promoted increased philanthropic and nonprofit accountability.

More about: Management and LeadershipOpinionThe Cohen Report

Become a member

Support independent journalism and knowledge creation for civil society. Become a member of Nonprofit Quarterly.

Members receive unlimited access to our archived and upcoming digital content. NPQ is the leading journal in the nonprofit sector written by social change experts. Gain access to our exclusive library of online courses led by thought leaders and educators providing contextualized information to help nonprofit practitioners make sense of changing conditions and improve infra-structure in their organizations.

Join Today
logo logo logo logo logo
See comments

Spring-2023-sidebar-subscribe
You might also like
Hierarchy and Justice
Cyndi Suarez
Salvadoran Foreign Agent Law Threatens Human Rights Movements
Devon Kearney
Charitable Tax Reform: Why Half Measures Won’t Curb Plutocracy
Alan Davis
Healing-Centered Leadership: A Path to Transformation
Shawn A. Ginwright
Into the Fire: Lessons from Movement Conflicts
Ingrid Benedict, Weyam Ghadbian and Jovida Ross
How Nonprofits Can Truly Advance Change
Hildy Gottlieb

NPQ Webinars

June 14th, 2:00pm ET

Remaking the Economy

Race for Profit

Register Now
June 22nd, 12:30 pm ET

Making Co-CEOs Work

Insights from Leaders Sharing Leadership Successfully

Register Now
July 12th, 2:00 pm ET

Remaking the Economy

Tenant Organizing in Unexpected Places

Register Now
You might also like
Hierarchy and Justice
Cyndi Suarez
Salvadoran Foreign Agent Law Threatens Human Rights...
Devon Kearney
Charitable Tax Reform: Why Half Measures Won’t Curb...
Alan Davis

Like what you see?

Subscribe to the NPQ newsletter to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

See our newsletters

By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.

NPQ-Spring-2023-cover

Independent & in your mailbox.

Subscribe today and get a full year of NPQ for just $59.

subscribe
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Copyright
  • Careers

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

 

Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.