logo
  • Nonprofit News
  • Management
    • Boards and Governance
    • Communication
      • Framing & Narratives
    • Ethics
    • Financial Management
    • Grassroots Fundraising Journal
    • Leadership
    • Technology
  • Philanthropy
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Donor-Advised Funds
    • Foundations
    • Impact Investing
    • Research
    • Workplace Giving
  • Policy
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Housing
    • Government
    • Taxes
  • Economic Justice
    • About
    • Economy Remix
    • Economy Webinars
    • Community Benefits
    • Economic Democracy
    • Environmental Justice
    • Fair Finance
    • Housing Rights
    • Land Justice
    • Poor People’s Rights
    • Tax Fairness
  • Racial Equity
  • Social Movements
    • Community Development
    • Community Organizing
    • Culture Change
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Gender Equality
    • Immigrant Rights
    • Indigenous Rights
    • Labor
    • LGBTQ+
    • Racial Justice
    • Youth Activism
  • About Us
  • Log in
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Featured Articles
  • Webinars
    • Free Webinars
    • Premium On-Demand Webinars
  • Tiny Spark Podcast
  • Magazine
    • Magazine
    • Leading Edge Membership
Donate
Policy

The Justice Department Presses On with Contraception Access Appeal

Erin Rubin
April 26, 2017
Share22
Share1
Email
Tweet
Artist not credited (Argument in an Off Key.) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

April 25, 2017; Washington Post

There’s a significant amount of fear building around women’s health issues in the Trump presidency: the “global gag rule,” the threats to Planned Parenthood, and of course the general conduct of the president towards women. This week, however, we see a small glimmer of hope, as the Justice Department maintains for now its appeal of a district court decision allowing religious nonprofits to opt out of providing contraception to female employees.

The Affordable Care Act requires employer-sponsored health insurance plans to provide preventative care, including contraception. Churches are exempt from this requirement for reasons of religious freedom. Religiously affiliated nonprofits, like universities or shelters, do not themselves have to pay for this service but must provide access for their employees to third-party administrators or alternative health plans that “would arrange for a health insurance issuer to provide contraceptive coverage to plan participants and beneficiaries without cost sharing, premium, fee, or other charge to plan participants or beneficiaries or to the eligible organization or its plan.”

Some groups say this doesn’t go far enough and would like nonprofits to be categorized with churches so they don’t have to deal with contraception at all. The most recent court ruling was in their favor, but the Justice Department asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit “for an additional 60 days to negotiate with East Texas Baptist University and several other religious groups objecting to a requirement to which they are morally opposed,” according to the Washington Post.

While women’s rights advocates may celebrate a Justice Department fighting for their rights, it is confusing why a department led by the notoriously hardline conservative Jeff Sessions would do this.

President Trump had initially indicated that he supported the groups campaigning against providing any kind of contraception. In a letter to Catholic leaders a month before the presidential election, he wrote:

Hillary Clinton supports forcing The Little Sisters of the Poor, who have taken care of the elderly poor since 1839, pay for contraceptives in their health care plan (even though they have never wanted them, never used them and never will), and having the government fine them heavily if they continue to refuse to abide by this onerous mandate.

That is a hostility to religious liberty you will never see in a Trump administration.

Despite this statement, Trump has neither asked the Justice Department to drop the appeal nor sought a change to the rules from the Department of Health & Human Services.

Though abortion is a divisive issue, contraception is less so. According to a study from the Guttmacher Institute, “More than 99 percent of women aged 15–44 who have ever had sexual intercourse have used at least one contraceptive method.” Most people who use contraception are married women, and the group putting itself at greatest risk for unintended conception is teenagers, ages 15-19. Forty-three million American women are at risk of unintended pregnancy if they aren’t able to get contraception.

Trump’s administration is no friend to women’s health access; two weeks ago, he signed a law rolling back an Obama-era regulation and now allows states to withhold federal family planning dollars from healthcare organizations that provide abortions. Since then, 23 states have taken measures to make contraception more easily available to women.

Another study from the Guttmacher Institute showed that “historical research has linked state laws granting unmarried women early legal access to the pill (at age 17 or 18, rather than 21), to their attainment of postsecondary education and employment, increased earning power and a narrowing of the gender gap in pay, and later, more enduring marriages.” Giving women the power to control if and when they have children is in everyone’s best interest.

However, the fact that birth control access is in the rational best interest of millions of people may not stop its being taken away. Who knows what the Justice Department is up to, but nonprofits will need to watch closely.— Erin Rubin

Share22
Share1
Email
Tweet

About The Author
Erin Rubin

Erin Rubin is an assistant editor at the Nonprofit Quarterly, where she is in charge of online editorial coordination and community building. Before joining NPQ, in 2016, Erin worked as an administrator at Harvard Business School and as an editorial project manager at Pearson Education, where she helped develop a digital resource library for remedial learners. Erin has also worked with David R. Godine, Publishers, and the Association of Literary Scholars, Critics, and Writers. As a creative lead with the TEDxBeaconStreet organizing team, she worked to help innovators and changemakers share their groundbreaking ideas and turn them into action.

Related
Advocates Warn of Looming Health Insurance Cliff
By Steve Dubb
September 29, 2020
Barring the Way to Justice: The Threat to Civil Society
By Carole Levine
September 29, 2020
Women’s Healthcare and Reproductive Rights: A Perpetual Target
By Carole Levine
September 3, 2020
Study Finds 12 Million Have Lost Employer-Based Health Insurance under COVID
By Steve Dubb
September 1, 2020
Millions of Americans Face Possible Loss of Health Coverage amid Pandemic
By Karen Kahn
July 28, 2020
In Times of Crisis, Watch Closely—or Your Rights May Disappear
By Martin Levine
March 31, 2020

Upcoming Webinars

Group Created with Sketch.
January 21, 2 pm ET

Remaking the Economy

Health, Racial Disparities, and Economic Justice

other posts by The Author
Law Students Call on States to Suspend the Bar—for Equity...
By Erin Rubin
July 28, 2020
Oklahoma Is Indian Country, Says SCOTUS—Now What?
By Erin Rubin
July 13, 2020
The Arrogance Trap: Why Elites Can’t Learn and Could Doom...
By Erin Rubin
June 24, 2020
CYNDI SUAREZ
The Nonprofit Racial Leadership Gap: Flipping the Lens
Powerful Interests Seek to Make Puerto Rico the Hong Kong of the...
Moving Beyond the Privilege of White Tears
logo
Donate
  • About
  • Contact
  • Newsletters
  • Write for NPQ
  • Advertise
  • Writers