Study Points to Key Advantage of Public or Nonprofit Higher Ed

June 1, 2012; Source: Washington Post

There has been a longtime conservative trope that the availability of student aid drives up college tuition levels. According to a critique of the concept written by David L. Warren, president of the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities, the theory was promoted by William Bennett, the former secretary of the U.S. Department of Education, who argued three decades ago that “student aid has… given colleges and universities ‘license’ to increase tuition, meaning that federal student aid has not made higher education more accessible or more affordable.”

According to Warren, “There is not a shred of empirical evidence of a causal relationship between federal student aid and tuition increases at public and private nonprofit institutions, including institutions with high published prices and large endowments.” He calls the Bennett hypothesis “nothing more than an urban legend.” Warren contends, “Inflation-adjusted net tuition (published tuition minus grants from all sources and federal higher education tax benefits) at private nonprofit colleges has actually dropped by 4.1 percent in the past five years.”

The Wall Street Journal added an interesting additional dimension to the argument this week. While tuition assistance does not drive up tuition costs at public colleges and private nonprofit colleges, the WSJ reports that, “a new study found that tuition at for-profit schools where students receive federal aid was 75% higher than at comparable for-profit schools whose students don’t receive any aid.” The WSJ authors attribute the lack of a similar dynamic at public and nonprofit schools to the fact that such schools “aren’t motivated by profits and because their prices are largely determined by state funding and donations.”

The representative of the for-profit college sector disagrees. The president of the Association of Private Sector Colleges and Universities is Steve Gunderson, who only last year was heading a nonprofit trade association, the Council on Foundations. Now running the trade association of for-profit schools, Gunderson, according to the WSJ, “disputes a link between federal aid and prices, saying (for-profit) colleges merely respond to market demand.”

According to the Journal, in contrast to Gunderson’s statement, “A spokesman for Education Secretary Arne Duncan said the administration believes there is a link between federal aid and tuition increases at for-profit schools, but that it sees no such tie with public and nonprofit schools.”

Why is this story important, aside from the obvious and continuing debate in Congress about increasing, decreasing, or eliminating federal assistance for college tuition? It is important because the study result cited in the Journal documents—more clearly than most studies—the distinctive advantage of the nonprofit model over the for-profit structure in higher education.—Rick Cohen

  • Prada outlet online

    Shopping for [B][LINK=http://www.pradaoutletshopping.com]Prada outlet online[/LINK][/B] is the best way to economize for you and your family. You’re going to get the most effective prices, as a result of the shops shouldn’t have as much overhead online as they’ve of their bodily stores; such as: Prada Handbags,Prada shoes,Prada Sunglasses,Prada belts,Prada wallets and etc.All at http://www.pradaoutletshopping.com ,on discount!

  • Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet

    [b][i][URL=http://www.louisvuittonbagoutletsale.com ]Louis Vuitton Bags Outlet[/URL][/i][/b] Online stores many of the instances will have a special and better price online then they have of Louis Vuitton shops, usually round 20 to 45% discount. Because they need to encourage you to buy online to construct up Louis Vuitton online (http://www.louisvuittonbagoutletsale.com ,) presence, as a result of they’re trying to go global. So shop online to save more.Usually these ” Louis Vuitton Online Shopping ” may have round 2000 stores or extra on their website and they’ll have made preparations with most or all of Louis Vuitton Bags stores, (your favorite stores you frequently store at), to offer their buyers even more further reductions, which may add as much as 50% off, by going by them every time similar to a physical mall.

  • Milan Moravec

    Searching for the priciest public university in USA? Your answer is University of California Berkeley. Access, affordability to University is farther and farther out of reach. University of California Berkeley Chancellor Robert J Birgeneau is outspoken on why elite public Cal. should ‘charge Californians much more’. Number 1 ranked Harvard is now less costly (all in costs) than Cal. Birgeneau’s ‘charge much more’ makes Cal. the most expensive American public university!

    Birgeneau ($450,000 salary) likes to blame the politicians, since they stopped giving him every dollar expected. The Chancellor’s ‘charge Californians more’ tuition skyrocketed fees by an average 14% per year from 2006 to 2011-12 academic years. If Birgeneau had allowed fees to rise at the same rate of inflation over the past 10 years they would still be in reach of most middle income students. A sad unacceptable legacy for students, parents, politicians

    The economic downturn is devastating California. Simply asking taxpayers for more money to fund inept leadership, old higher education models and support burdensome faculty, chancellor salaries/benefits is not the answer. Additional funding should sunset.

    UC Berkeley is to maximize access to the widest number of Californians at a reasonable cost: mission of diversity and equality of opportunity. Birgeneau’s and Provost George Breslauer’s ($306,000 salary) ‘charge Californians more’ tuition denies middle income Californians the transformative value of Cal’s higher education.

    Opinions? UC Board of Regents marsha.kelman@ucop.edu Calif. State Senators, Assembly members.