In Utah, More Scouts but Less Money, and Mass LDS Resignations over New Baptism Policy

Print Share on LinkedIn More

Eunika Sopotnicka /

November 12, 2015; KUTV-TV (Salt Lake City, UT)

The fact that the Boy Scouts have not raised as much as in previous years in Utah may have less to do with the new more liberal policy at the BSA and more to do with a growing split between the Mormon Church and its parishioners on LGBT issues.

The largest Boy Scouts branch in the country (and getting larger) is based in Orem, Utah. The Utah National Parks Council serves 90,000 scouts, of which 94 percent are Mormon. Stan Lockhart, the president of the council, says their membership numbers are at an all-time high and are expected to grow by 44 percent over the next 20 years. Despite all that growth, though, Lockhart says some of its 70 employees may be laid off as a result of recent fundraising shortfalls.

Without saying by how much it is short, he blames the problem on the recent decision to allow gay scout leaders. Local charter branches are free to choose their own leaders, even if they decide to discriminate, but the National body was clear that any lawsuits would be handled by those local groups. While there were worries about the possibility that the LDS church would sever its ties, that did not happen; instead, it opted to retain its relationship with the Boy Scouts.

Rick Barnes, executive leader of the Great Salt Lake Council, the second-largest council in Utah, says there is ongoing confusion about the church’s stance. Barnes said his branch purposely postponed their fundraising campaign following the national ruling, and this whole scene provides some clue about why fundraising may be down. If the branches are cautious and uncomfortable about their position within the community given the new policy, it may very well be that that feeling transmits itself to donors. The fact that membership numbers are up, on the other hand, may indicate that the community is less concerned than are the church and the council leaders.

Meanwhile, a new rule that disallows children of same-sex couples from receiving baptism and participating in naming ceremonies is creating a furor within the church itself. The New York Times reports that the rule was evidently not meant to be made public, but it was sent in a confidential email to leaders of 30,000 congregations. Soon leaked to the news media, the provision created a wave of 1500 resignations from the church on Saturday.—Ruth McCambridge

  • Morm on

    The President of the Corporation of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, aka Tommy Monson (TPotCotCoJCoLDS) reminds me of the captain of the Titanic. “Ooops….”

  • m2cts

    I applaud those 1500 people who turned their back to their faith. Religions claim truth but in reality they are nothing but traditions which change all the time, proving their arbitrariness.

  • Steven Jones

    Does this sound like a non-profit organization to anyone?

    Bob Mazzuca, former Chief Scout Executive, BSA, 2012 was paid over $1.2 million plus pension and perks.

    Wayne Brock was paid over $1.5 million plus pension and perks as he took over in 2013.

    Roy Williams, the fifth highest-paid non-profit CEO in America at the time, pulled down a whopping $1.6 million.

    Robert Gates, recently taking the chair in 2014 as BSA’s Chief Scout Executive, pays himself over $2 million annually in compensation, salary, benefits, pensions, insurance premiums, and other miscellaneous perks and benefits.

    Numerous additional BSA Scout Executives currently pay themselves well over $450,000 annually.

    Dozens of other BSA Scout Executives (including the Great Salk Lake Council) make over $250,000 annually, not including benefits or pension plans.