June 19, 2014; Pittsburgh Tribune-Review
Don’t knock on doors in Baldwin, Pennsylvania to solicit money for a nonprofit unless you’re carrying your registration. Stephanie Hacke reports for the Tribune-Review that Baldwin has passed an ordinance requiring members of nonprofit, religious, and charitable organizations to register with the Baldwin police before they solicit for anything on a door-to-door basis.
Sign up for our free newsletters
Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.
Baldwin’s previous solicitation ordinance had covered commercial solicitors who were selling or advertising door-to-door or house-to-house, but exempted political and religious organizations. The new requirement is that nonprofit and charitable solicitors have to submit a criminal record check and a valid driver’s license. In addition, a resident of Baldwin who gets a house-to-house solicitation permit would pay $15 a week, $50 a month, or $75 for three months; a nonresident would pay $10 a day for the privilege of soliciting.
The free speech issues in the Baldwin ordinance virtually jump off the page. After being contacted by a nonprofit that would have had to register 20 people it had recruited to administer a house-to-house survey, the American Civil Liberties Union has contacted the Borough to suggest that the ordinance violates the First Amendment.
With a population of some 20,000, Baldwin Borough’s slogan is, “Just a nice place to live!” Located in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area, Baldwin may be a lovely place, but it is difficult to think of it as a good “nice place” if it enacts laws that violate constitutional free speech protections.—Rick Cohen