logo
  • Nonprofit News
  • Management
    • Boards and Governance
    • Communication
      • Framing & Narratives
    • Ethics
    • Financial Management
    • Fund Development
    • Leadership
    • Technology
  • Philanthropy
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
    • Donor-Advised Funds
    • Foundations
    • Impact Investing
    • Research
    • Workplace Giving
  • Policy
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Housing
    • Government
    • Taxes
  • Economic Justice
    • Economy Remix
    • Economy Webinars
    • Community Benefits
    • Economic Democracy
    • Environmental Justice
    • Fair Finance
    • Housing Rights
    • Land Justice
    • Poor People’s Rights
    • Tax Fairness
  • Racial Equity
  • Social Movements
    • Community Development
    • Community Organizing
    • Culture Change
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Gender Equality
    • Immigrant Rights
    • Indigenous Rights
    • Labor
    • LGBTQ+
    • Racial Justice
    • Youth Activism
  • About Us
  • Log in
  • CONTENT TYPES
  • Webinars
    • Leading Edge Membership
    • Sponsored Webinars
    • Economic Justice
  • Tiny Spark Podcast
  • Magazine
    • Magazine
    • Leading Edge Membership
Donate
Community Activism, Michigan, Transparency

Cost of Flint’s Water Crisis: $50,000 per Child

Jim Schaffer
August 12, 2016
Share54
Tweet
Share2
Email
56 Shares
Flint-water
By U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, photographer not specified or unknown [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

August 9, 2016; The Atlantic

“Apparently, it’s going to be a thing now,” wrote a spokeswoman for the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality in an internal email when the media began asking questions about the tainted drinking water in Flint. Now that it has long since been “a thing,” public health officials are attempting to calculate the financial cost of the atrocity.

Peter Muennig at Columbia University’s Mailman School of Public Health estimates the total cost to be $458 million: $58 million is what the state paid for providing medical care and unleaded water; $400 million is the estimated long-term human cost. The lifelong bill reckons $50,000 per child exposed to lead. This amount apparently covers the afflicted person’s lifetime of low economic productivity, need for all manner of welfare programs, and the cost of the criminal justice system to manage the violence that results from lead poisoning. Flint documented more than 8,000 cases of exposure to lead. How tidy to be able to sum it up like that.

The point of the Atlantic article and the case that Muennig is trying to make is that cost of prevention is far less than the consequences.

Those costs can be rendered in the interest of maximizing human well-being or simply protecting a municipal bottom line, depending on one’s priorities. Either way, confronting the cost up-front—for public-health measures as for so many things in life—tends to be difficult. It also tends to divide people along political lines.

“Hopefully these numbers generate some feedback and controversy,” he laughs. […] “I just think it’ll be controversial because people feel weird about spending money on social programs.”

A life of suffering, of lost potential, of experiencing more aggression than contentment is a cost impossible to measure and just as difficult to assimilate. Lead poisoning causes significant biological and neurologic damage. Children are particularly vulnerable to lead. Exposure can cause stunted growth, permanent cognitive disability, speech impairment, hearing loss, reproductive problems, and kidney damage. In the words of Dioscorides, the second century B.C. Greek physician, “Lead makes the mind give way.”

The most important number offered up by Muennig? 1760. “That’s the number of years of healthy human life that have been sacrificed due to lead poisoning in Flint so far.”

Michael Moore, a Flint resident, offered a solid analysis of what happened and why. To sum up, Governor Rick Snyder appointed emergency managers for a number of the state’s economically distressed municipalities at risk of insolvency, including Flint. Flint’s appointed manager decided to save money by switching its supply from Detroit’s, which draws upon Lake Huron, to the Flint River. The Flint River is infamously filthy, but the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality insists the water is just fine. As stated in a New Yorker commentary, “Residents’ tap water turns smelly and brown and tastes weird. Complaints are ignored. The state’s Department of Environmental Quality insists that the water is fine—maybe there’s some rust, an occasional finding of E. coli.” President Obama eventually declared a federal state of emergency and the National Guard was deployed to distribute bottled water.

Some 8,000 lives exposed later, the problems caused by the decision to use Flint River water remain unresolved and expensive to fix.

Hence the case for cold numeric calculation. Previous calculations have estimated that for every dollar spent preventing lead poisoning, the benefit would be $10.50. Even with return like that, Muennig sees it as politically unviable to spend the necessary tens of billions of dollars to identify all houses built within with a risk of lead leaching into the water supply and trying to replace their pipes. “That might fly in Scandinavia, but not here,” he said.

Flint reveals the face of poverty. It’s not just lack and deprivation, but the choices others force upon the poor, such as permitting poisoned water to flow to every home. We express horror and indignation. We demand change. Snyder remains in office and Flint is not in the news much these days.

What about those 8,000 lives (and counting) forever crippled by the countless bureaucratic cost/benefit decisions made to keep the water flowing? What are their names? Who are their parents? What will be their stories? Thankfully, as NPQ reported, Flint Public Library and StoryCorps joined forces to archive first-person accounts of those affected by the poisoning of Flint’s water supply. Each of these lives has value: Each is priceless.—James Schaffer

Share54
Tweet
Share2
Email
56 Shares

About The Author
Jim Schaffer

The founders of Covenant House, AmeriCares, TechnoServe and the Hole in the Wall Gang Camp were my mentors who entrusted me with much. What I can offer the readers of NPQ is carried out in gratitude to them and to the many causes I’ve had the privilege to serve through the years.

Related
State Control Is No Silver Bullet for School Reform
By Martin Levine
November 22, 2019
Jewish Nonprofit Employees Decide They Too Want Radical Salary Transparency
By Steve Dubb
November 21, 2019
Michigan Cities Fight for Federal Affordable Housing Crumbs
By Benjamin Martinez
November 18, 2019
Raising Consciousness on Civic Engagement: The Engaged Cities Award
By Derrick Rhayn
November 8, 2019
Fighting for the Right to Be Educated—A Youth Based Lawsuit Against Detroit Schools
By Martin Levine
November 1, 2019
Flint’s First Poet Laureate Sets a New Standard
By Erin Rubin
October 10, 2019
other posts by The Author
Though Silenced by an Assassin’s Bullet, St. Romero’s...
By Jim Schaffer
October 25, 2018
A City of Billionaires and Kids in Need: Homelessness in the...
By Jim Schaffer
October 22, 2018
Arkansas Public Media Collaboration Falters
By Jim Schaffer
October 16, 2018
A Series on Sensemaking Organizations
The Sensemaking Organization: Designing for Complexity
The Sensemaking Mindset: Improvisation over Strategy
Structuring for Sensemaking: The Power of Small Segments
logo
Donate
  • About
  • Contact
  • Newsletters
  • Write for NPQ
  • Advertise
  • Writers
  • Funders
  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy

Subscribe to View Webinars

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

 

Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly
Powered by GDPR plugin
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.