Board Members as Major-Gift Partners (Not Passengers)

Welcome back to NPQ’s fundraising advice column, Ask Rhea. Rhea Wong is a fundraising expert and professional coach, exuberant author of Get That Money, Honey! host of the Nonprofit Lowdown podcast, and an unfailingly encouraging voice in a sometimes-bleak landscape. Rhea wants you to succeed, and she’s here to answer your questions.

Have a fundraising question? Send it to this submission form and choose “Fundraising” from the drop-down menu.

Dear Rhea,

I joined the board of an organization I love. I’m smart, I’m connected, I’m generous. At my last board meeting, the executive director handed me a list and said, “Go ask your friends for money.”

I froze. If I call my friend Janet, won’t she think I’m only reaching out because I want something? Won’t she ask me back next time her cause needs money? I want to help but I just can’t bring myself to do this.

Am I a bad board member?

Sincerely,

Anxious Board Member

Dear Anxious Board Member,

You are not a bad board member. You are not lazy. You are not broken. You are having a completely rational response to a completely broken system.

Here is what no one told you when you joined this board. The model most nonprofits use for major gift fundraising was built 50 years ago, and it does not work on today’s donors. The model goes like this: Get a list of names. Make some calls. Ask for money. That is the entire strategy.

It is killing your relationships. It is killing your donor pipeline. And it is making good board members like you feel icky.

Real talk: You are being asked to do the wrong job. Your actual job is to be a partner in fundraising, not a salesperson for it. And once you understand the difference, everything changes.

The Villain in This Story

The villain is not your executive director. The villain is not you. The villain is not even your donors. The villain is a broken model that treats fundraising as solicitation and nothing else.

Here is what happens when you follow it. You get a list. You call your friend Janet without context. Janet thinks, “Why is she calling me? Oh. They want money.” She feels blindsided. She feels used. She writes a small check to make you go away.

Major gift fundraising is not a single act of asking. It is a six-stage process, and only one of those six stages is the ask.

Now, Janet will likely not give again. She will not introduce you to her three friends who actually have capacity. The organization just lost what could have been a $50,000 relationship because someone asked for $5,000 the wrong way.

Multiply that by every board member at every nonprofit in this country, and you start to see the scale of what is being left on the table.

This is not a board problem but rather a partnership problem. The board is being asked to operate alone, without context, without a process, and without a partner on the staff side who can carry the relationship forward. No wonder boards freeze.

Fundraising Is Not One Thing—It’s Six

The breakthrough that changes everything for board members is the realization that major-gift fundraising is not a single act of asking. It is a six-stage process, and only one of those six stages is the ask. The other five are things you already know how to do. You just did not know they counted.

Here are the six stages of a consent-based major gift process:

1. Engagement: An event, an introduction, a conversation where someone first hears about the work. No one is asking for anything.
2. Preliminary qualification: The confirmation of five things: They have capacity, they have a reason for giving, there is some kind of relationship, the timing is right, and we have permission to continue.
3. Qualification: A real conversation that clarifies their interest and invites them into a process.
4. Cultivation: The wining, dining, schmoozing, site visits, program tours. The getting-to-know-you phase.
5. Solicitation: A co-created proposal for funding. Not a random ask. A natural conversation, because the work was done up front.
6. Stewardship: The afterglow. Showing the donor what their gift made possible.

Look at where the board lives in this process. Board members lead in engagement. They help in preliminary qualification. They participate in qualification. They participate in cultivation. They participate in stewardship. Staff leads on solicitation.

Read that again. Out of six stages, the board only takes the lead in one (engagement) and staff leads on the ask. Every other stage is a partnership.

That is the reframe. You are not the closer. You are the connector, the host, the relationship builder, and the celebrant. The staff is the strategist, the qualifier, and the asker. Together, you are a team. Apart, you are both flailing.

Why Boards Freeze

When I work with board members and ask them to introduce someone in their network, the most common answer is, “I do not know any rich people.”

That is almost never the actual problem.

The actual problem usually sounds more like this: I do not trust what the staff is going to do with my contacts. I am afraid of being embarrassed. I have not had any meaningful conversations with the people closest to me about what they care about. I do not want my friend to feel hunted.

All of those fears are valid. All of them go away when there is a real partnership in place between the board and the staff.

Partnership means the board member knows what is going to happen to Janet after the introduction is made. Partnership means the staff member is not going to chase Janet like Jaws if she says no. Partnership means there is a shared agreement about who does what, when, and how Janet will be treated at every step. Partnership means the board member can call Janet six months later and Janet will say, “Oh, I love that organization you introduced me to. They have been wonderful to get to know.”

That is the shift from petitioner to partner. Not just for the donor. For the board member, too.

What Real Partnership Looks Like in Practice

There are a few practical things board members and staff can do together starting at the next board meeting to foster stronger partnerships, such as:

• Have a real conversation about who does what. Most boards have never had this conversation explicitly. They have a vague sense that fundraising is “everyone’s job,” which is functionally the same as being no one’s job. Get specific. Who opens doors? Who qualifies prospects? Who has the cultivation conversation? Who makes the ask? Write it down.
• Build a shared pipeline the board can actually see. If the only person who knows what is in the pipeline is the executive director, the board cannot govern. A simple shared document with prospect names, where they are in the six stages, the dollar potential, and next action is enough to start. It does not need to be fancy. It needs to be visible.
• Replace cold calls with warm hosting. Instead of asking board members to phone strangers, ask them to host. A salon-style dinner with eight to 10 guests, hosted in a board member’s home, with the executive director in the room to talk about the mission, opens more relationships in two hours than a month of cold calls. The board member’s job is to invite. The staff member’s job is to follow up. Two roles. One outcome.
• Brief board members before every introduction. No board member should be sent into a conversation cold. A two-minute briefing on the prospect, the talking points, what we know, what we are listening for, and what success looks like is the difference between a board member feeling prepared or ambushed.
• Debrief after every donor touchpoint. Most boards never close the loop. The board member makes the introduction, then hears nothing for six months, then assumes nothing happened. A simple debrief after each donor meeting builds trust and momentum. It also tells the board member their effort mattered.
• Steward your board members the way you steward your donors. Board members are donors of time, money, and social capital. If they are not being thanked, updated, and shown impact, they will quietly disengage. The same care you give a $50,000 donor is the care your board members deserve.

The Cost of Doing Nothing

Here is the part that should make any board member uncomfortable: The cost of staying in the broken model is not just one missed gift, it compounds.

This quarter, board paralysis could cost the organization $50,000 in unmade introductions. This year, it costs the December campaign. Next year, it costs the major donor who quietly went somewhere else because no one ever bothered to find out what she actually cared about.

A burned relationship is one of the hardest things to repair. Sometimes you do not get the donor back at all.

And while we are talking honestly, as a board member, you are responsible for the financial health of the organization. If you cannot get a clear answer about what is in the pipeline for next quarter, what is at risk, and where revenue is coming from, you are flying blind. That is not a fundraising problem. That is a governance problem. You cannot make strategic decisions about programming, hiring, or expansion if no one can tell you where the money is.

If it is not on the scorecard, it did not happen.

Three Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting

If you are a board member reading this, here is your move. Ask three questions at your next meeting:

1. How many qualified prospects are currently in our pipeline, and where is each one in the six stages?
2. What is the dollar value of proposals out right now, and when do we expect them to close?
3. What is my specific role in the next 90 days, and what is the staff’s specific role?

If those questions can be answered in 60 seconds, your board has a system and a partnership. If they cannot be answered, you do not have a system. You have a list. And a list is not a strategy.