
Why are some foundation executives content with rearranging furniture instead of being active partners in fixing the material realities of a shrinking nonprofit sector and, along with it, the social safety net millions rely on? A recent report from the Center of Effective Philanthropy may be unable to explain foundation behaviors but does shed light on the extent of institutional dawdling and misalignment in the nonprofit sector.
CEP’s data reveals a startling disconnect between acknowledging a crisis and actually deploying resources to solve it. What emerges in the latest report is a picture of profound paralysis. Foundation leaders are aware that the sector must evolve but remain locked into a status quo of resource hoarding.
What emerges in the latest report is a picture of profound paralysis.
According to survey responses from nearly 200 CEOs at the nation’s largest foundations, 98 percent acknowledge that foundations need to change to address society’s needs, yet only 14 percent believe such change is “very likely.” A large majority have chosen not to increase payouts, and the minority that has is moving from a legally mandated 5 percent to 6 or 7 percent at best. Consider the starkest example of the misalignment: Roughly 40 percent of foundation CEOs report offering “support beyond the grant,” yet a statistically negligible 1 percent of nonprofit leaders say non-financial assistance is what their organizations actually need.
This represents an enclosure of public benefit dollars at a time of escalating threats to our multiracial democracy and a crisis of resources—an enclosure that is fiercely protected by a wild distortion of risk.
When asked, foundation boards and executives routinely cite “legal risk” and “reputational risk” as justifications for inaction or for diluting their commitments to marginalized communities. Meanwhile, the actual, physical and material risks of democratic backsliding and this austerity are offloaded on a permanent underclass of nonprofit frontline workers and the communities they serve.
So, what happens when the elite retreat into privatized safety while the masses self-manage one systemic collapse after another? Instead of joining a cacophony of voices pleading for partnership, let me walk you through the probable future of operating this way. I know what this looks like because I grew up in it.
Consider the starkest example of the misalignment: Roughly 40 percent of foundation CEOs report offering “support beyond the grant,” yet a statistically negligible 1 percent of nonprofit leaders say non-financial assistance is what their organizations actually need.
Spending my childhood and young adulthood across New Delhi, Jaipur, Kathmandu, Doha, and Dubai in the 1980s and 1990s, the physical weight of scarcity was a daily reality. In more than one location, because municipal power and water rarely arrived at the same time, we routinely hauled heavy buckets of water from the ground floor up to our second-floor residence. When it did flow at the same time, we were able to fill rooftop cisterns to create the illusion of “running water.” I frequently studied by the flickering light of kerosene lamps or candles—as did my friends—all from solidly middle-class families.
But the most jarring scenes of my otherwise normal childhood were the visuality of extremes; beautiful, manicured gated compounds and high rises next to sprawling slums. Class apartheid simply accepted as the natural order.
Sign up for our free newsletters
Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.
This is the future we are sleepwalking towards—the result, in part, of foundation executives and boards sitting on their hands. A future defined by extreme wealth inequality, a permanent underclass that keeps the economy functioning, and the visible signs of institutional rot.
Does it seem far-fetched? An improbable future that only exists in faraway countries in the Global South?
Where I live now in the Pacific Northwest, power outages are more frequent, arriving a few times a year. Elsewhere, in Gary, Indiana, hundreds of thousands went without power for nearly two weeks. The Southwest and California’s Central Valley are frequently under water conservation orders. Many reservations do without both these necessities, having never been connected to power grids and municipal water lines.
This is the future we are sleepwalking towards—the result, in part, of foundation executives and boards sitting on their hands.
Beyond the United States, the frustration of under-resourced and systematically marginalized groups is boiling over. In India, we saw the Gen Z “cockroach party” protest, a massive youth-led movement fueled by a graduate unemployment rate that stands between 35 and 40 percent. While US youth unemployment currently sits at roughly 10 percent, economic precarity is already hollowing out the very social sector positioned to fight it. United for ALICE’s data consistently shows that one-in-four nonprofit workers do not earn enough to make ends meet.
Instead of deploying financial resources to solve these crises, the philanthropic sector hoards it. The United States has just over 150,000 private foundations. Along with donor advised funds, there is roughly $2.2 trillion in philanthropic assets sitting unspent. This accumulation is heavily subsidized; tax incentives for charitable contributions cost the public treasury at least $50 billion annually in forgone federal tax revenue.
Richard Posner calls perpetual charitable foundations a “completely irresponsible institution, answerable to nobody.”
Within what can only be described as a structural lock-in, the sector financially incentivizes organizations to “love the problem” rather than end them. Nonprofits are forced to frame their communities in the most dire terms possible to secure funding. The result is an expensive game played to prop up a global work machine that lives by spreadsheets and slides, not solutions.
Correcting will require a fundamental shift in how each player in this game operates. Points of unity cannot merely be based on identity or feel-good rhetoric; they must be rooted in shared strategies for building actual material power. We can imagine a different future, but it starts with the sector’s gatekeepers truly listening to the frontline workers they have repeatedly sidelined—and then acting on what they’ve heard.