
Participatory grantmaking is a growing but underutilized practice across philanthropy. The approach focuses on shifting power and decision making to community, stakeholders, and those with lived experience to inform and direct resources to promising solutions. The desired results are investments better reflecting community needs and priorities.
Over the last year, our team at NEO Philanthropy worked alongside an advisory committee of leaders with lived experience and professional expertise to design and implement a national participatory grantmaking pilot for the research and data initiative of the Economic Mobility and Opportunity Fund. The multi-million-dollar initiative was designed to learn from new grantmaking strategies and governance processes with a focus on increasing the upward mobility of individuals across the United States. Along the way we found ourselves unlearning assumptions about how power is shared, how decisions are made, and how to design an equitable grantmaking process.
What is participatory grantmaking?
Participatory grantmaking (PGM) is a core approach to how we do our work, not because it is trendy or en vogue, but because of what is learned, produced, and adopted as a result of the PGM process and outcomes. The Strategic Partnership Programs team at NEO has worked the past five years with pooled funds, individual donors, and institutional funders to distribute over $10 million in funding through participatory processes. Each project helped us move resources closer to communities impacted by the problems we are aiming to solve, from advancing post-secondary success for underserved students to increasing economic opportunities for low-income communities.
As we enter a new era of philanthropy, we must be willing to examine who holds power, along with the practices, assumptions, and beliefs that define how power is exercised.
By expanding the table of decision makers to include leaders with lived experience and contextual knowledge, we’ve deepened our understanding of issues and increased our awareness of organizations leading work on the ground. It served as a mirror, reflecting where our own practices can better support the needs of the community while constantly pushing us beyond the status quo of traditional philanthropy.
Developing the PGM process at NEO has brought us to question what philanthropy accepts as standard practice and challenged us to unlearn assumptions we’ve carried into our work. As we enter a new era of philanthropy, we must be willing to examine who holds power, along with the practices, assumptions, and beliefs that define how power is exercised.
How power is shared
When it comes to shifting power, it doesn’t amount to structural or procedural changes. It requires emotional care and delicacy within the process.
We often assume that if we invite community members in, compensate them for their experience and expertise, and cede decision-making power, that a participatory experience will feel inherently empowering. NEO’s PMG process taught us that shifting power can also feel heavy.
Resource allocation, particularly among under-supported organizations and communities with great need, is difficult. Our process revealed that many of our committee members felt the guilt, discomfort, and responsibility of holding the funding decisions, especially when the need for funding outweighed available resources.
Several were grantseekers at a point themselves and often had relationships or deep ties to the community and organizations represented in the applicant pool. This meant the stakes felt incredibly high, and those in the room felt additional pressure. They deeply desired to make fair and reasoned funding decisions but felt the weight and accountability to the people and communities that would be affected by their decisions.
A common question emerged: “Why me?” Underneath the question was something deeper: “Am I the right person to make such a big decision? Who am I to decide who receives resources and who doesn’t?”
At this moment, our facilitation is beyond procedural effort and into a form of care. Instead of rushing through the discomfort, we explored the feelings of guilt, power, and stewardship. We reflected on how traditional, institutional philanthropy has been normalized as the ultimate decision makers, shaping our collective consciousness on who we give authority to decide. We reminded them that a goal of our PGM process was to expand decision-making power by elevating more diverse voices and lived experience into the grantmaking process.
Through our facilitation, peer sharing, and reflections, we helped to move the conversation from “Who am I to be making this decision?” to “How can my proximity, relationships, expertise, and knowledge be used to make informed decisions?”
Most importantly, we reminded the committee that opting out does not make the decision disappear. Someone will still decide—and in this case their knowledge, proximity, and lived experience served as authority and expertise.
Sign up for our free newsletters
Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.
How decisions are made
One of the key motivations for implementing PGM was to expand who holds decision-making power and what we recognize as expertise. Our goal of inviting a community-based advisory committee was to center their lived experience, expertise, issue area context, and relationships. By broadening the perspectives that informed our decisions, we hoped to move resources to organizations that are often overlooked or excluded from a traditional grantmaking process.
Resource allocation, particularly among under-supported organizations and communities with great need, is difficult.
Like many grantmaking processes, we used a scoring rubric to help narrow selections, guide decision-making, and ultimately reduce bias. The rubric was designed to provide consistency and help reviewers score applicants based on agreed upon priorities.
We quickly learned that our rubric was the starting point of deliberation, not the end of it. Evaluating based on scores alone reproduced decision-making norms that we hoped our PGM process would challenge. And so, we challenged them: It was important in our deliberation that we considered not only the application performance against the predetermined criteria, but also created space for contextual and community knowledge, relationships, and lived experience.
The goal wasn’t to abandon rigor, but to expand what we considered rigorous.
How to design an equitable grantmaking process
During the design phase of our request for proposals (RFP), our advisory committee spent time exploring different grantmaking approaches. One of our shared goals was to design an equitable process that would reach nonprofits who are often underfunded, overlooked or disconnected from research and data funding opportunities.
Our advisory committee initially associated an open process naturally with equity and accessibility. The thinking was that if everyone who met the criteria had an opportunity to apply, then we’d have designed an equitable process. While we ultimately decided on an open RFP design, we had to deeply interrogate how it supported our shared goal of increased equity and access.
While there is no panacea, the choice of an open or closed RFP should be guided by your goal, context, and desired outcomes.
We learned that equity is not a byproduct of access, especially when applicants are starting from different places. An open RFP process can unearth projects and applicants that funders may not otherwise encounter. Broad access can increase competition, privilege those with resources like grant writers and development officers, and favor those that have time and human capacity and are already connected to existing funding opportunities and the philanthropic ecosystem. A closed or targeted process presents its own tradeoffs and limitations. It can reduce competition and increase invited applicants’ likelihood of receiving funding; however, it does ultimately change how the net gets cast.
While there is no panacea, the choice of an open or closed RFP should be guided by your goal, context, and desired outcomes. Both are design choices with consequences for who gets access, who bears the burden, and ultimately who gets funded. This became an important point of unlearning for us. Rather than asking “Should this RFP be open, closed or targeted?” we learned to ask, “What are we trying to make more equitable, for whom, and what design choice gets us closer to that outcome?”
Our committee continued to interrogate the conditions of the full RFP experience, from eligibility criteria, principles, technical assistance offerings, and time and capacity requirements. Equity was intentionally designed across the full RFP design, not just whether the application was open or closed.
When we expand who gets to decide, we are able to expand what is possible, including who gets funded, what knowledge is valuable, and which solutions can take root. That is the promise of sharing power. Community expertise and lived experience don’t belong on the sidelines, they belong at the center of how decisions are made.
PGM also has the potential to transform more than the grantmaking process and outcomes. It can transform the grantmaker or funder too. Perhaps this is one of our most valuable lessons: to see participatory grantmaking not simply as a service offered, but as a shared practice that continually asks us to look in the mirror and examine our assumptions, practices, and beliefs.
To learn more about participatory grantmaking, NEO Philanthropy offers strategic advising, design, and implementation for bespoke donor and funder initiatives.