
Philanthropy has spent generations positioning itself as a foundational pillar of civil rights and social justice work in this country. So, why aren’t we treating these exits as a betrayal of the very role philanthropy has defined for itself? And, most importantly, what are we doing as a sector to chart a new path forward to sustain our collective efforts to advance social justice?
In the past three months, multiple foundations have announced previously unplanned moves to wind down their funding allocations on multiple issues, such as immigration and LGBTQ+ rights. These funders have joined Wellspring Philanthropic Fund and several other institutions that have made the same decision in the past two years.
For example, just a few months ago—without a major announcement—Foundation for a Just Society quietly made alarming cuts to its domestic social justice portfolio. In parallel, a number of reproductive health, rights, and justice funders have been swiftly and silently cutting back funding for movement-building reproductive justice organizations—even before Dobbs v. Jackson overturned the federal constitutional right to abortion. This has been happening in the backdrop of even more funders that significantly cut their funding for racial justice in recent years, with especially violent funding cuts for pro-Palestine organizations.
NoVo Foundation’s abrupt 2020 exit from gender-violence funding foreshadowed exactly the kind of compounding damage done to the fields left behind. NoVo Foundation accounted for roughly 96 percent of all US funding, specifically targeted at curbing gender violence. That rollback not only fractured the foundation’s support for the gender justice movement, but it also widened existing disparities in funding for women of color, since it previously accounted for 37 percent of all funding aimed specifically at Black women’s rights and organizers.
What are we doing as a sector to chart a new path forward to sustain our collective efforts to advance social justice?
What complicates this climate is that some funders are exiting for more principled reasons, specifically rejecting the funding practice of hoarding immense resources in perpetuity. These funders have been engaging in intentional, long-planned spend-downs, announced with enough years in advance for at least some planning to take place by movement organizations. However, combined with the newer, unplanned departures by significantly larger funders, these principled exits create an unfortunate situation that becomes undiscernible to movement organizations who don’t know where to go next.
Right now, our movement still has an opportunity to protect our infrastructure and weather these funding shifts. As an active leader in the Block and Build Funder Coalition, I am already engaged in conversations about unlocking new dollars and building new pathways for movement groups to overcome the gaps in philanthropy—and I know there are many conversations happening outside of this container. This is an opportunity to capitalize on emergent strategies that capture opportunistic moments for long-arc organizing. By prioritizing a clear philanthropic organizing strategy, we can directly replace the retracted funding we’ve already lost, while replacing future gaps we know are still coming. This same organizing strategy could also add more professional, institutionalized funders to the field. While we can’t stop the harm that has already been done, we can still identify and build a long-term sustainability strategy for our movement—one that lasts.
Charting a path forward
Many of my fellow organizers regularly quote The Revolution Will Not Be Funded, but the critique outlined by INCITE! in this book wasn’t an argument to entirely walk away from institutional philanthropy—it was a call to stop letting philanthropy define its own terms. This reading is certainly an essential resource for any movement comrade or philanthropic organizer, and its warning about the nonprofit industrial complex remains true throughout the 19 years since it was published. However, I argue that while the revolution itself may not be funded, the infrastructure we currently need to revolutionize the sector and hold philanthropy accountable, needs to be funded and sustained.
Here are some proposed next steps that I hope we can collectively execute across the sector. I invite partners to join me and Emergent Fund to collaboratively work together to create this much needed change:
- Map the field
The first step is mapping the field of all lost funding, specifically by issue area and funder/dollars lost, so that we know exactly where the gaps exist, what we need to replace, and by when. Some philanthropic infrastructure organizations have already done some of this work for specific issue areas, but we need this to be expanded more broadly for a holistic approach—one that looks across all issue areas—and we must look further back than just the last few years ago to capture the full impact.
Philanthropy has spent generations positioning itself as a foundational pillar of civil rights and social justice work in this country.
- Build the team
Once we understand the full scope, we need to build a strategic group of wealth managers, donor advisors, philanthropists, and high-net-worth donors willing to organize around this work and specifically fund the gaps identified. We must identify new wealthy families capable of creating new institutional foundations. But to do this, we must abandon philanthropic self-interest norms, because advisors and funders hoarding their own business and donor relationships should not come before rebuilding the field. This strategy only works if the people at the table are willing to activate meaningful relationships, even risk short-term financial reward, for the greater good of philanthropy in the long term. That is, these same professionals, firms, and organizations could partner in building and stewarding these new foundations.
Sign up for our free newsletters
Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.
- Balance access and execution
This group needs to be intentionally diverse in what it brings to the table, and this should extend beyond just who is in the room. While we need people with direct access to a higher echelon of wealthy individuals, we also need people with the capacity to execute. These two groups aren’t necessarily one and the same. We need a team of philanthropic organizers ready to steward, manage, and organize the access-holders and who understand philanthropic infrastructure. They may rarely, if ever, sit across from an ultra-high net wealth individual themselves, but know the movement’s needs, and how to build different institutional models, including fiscal sponsorship.
- Get to the issues: Be specific and replicate
This work will need to get deeply specific and the efforts underway should match the identified need. Hypothetically, if we forecast that $100 million annually will disappear from reproductive justice funding over the next three years because four foundations will no longer fund the movement, that forecast should come with a working list of prospective families, relevant advisors, or people to engage with, as well as relevant networks or relationships to pursue leads. All of this work builds on the assumption that most funders will say no (a fundraising practice staple), which means all prospect lists should be targeted but with enough of a realistic pipeline to “close” the gaps. Earlier, I recommended mapping the field across sectors to be inclusive of all issue areas, so if our approach is to start with one focus, we should replicate this singular strategy per movement issue area. I do not believe in making a vague appeal—we need to be specific in our needs as we actively get to work to rebuild and expand our field.
Philanthropic investments for civil rights
Our movement for social justice has gotten this far in part because of cumulative acts of social justice and philanthropic networks throughout history. We can learn from these brave moments, leverage them, and go even further if we act to push for change while we still can.
For example, in 1917 Booker T. Washington partnered with Julius Rosenwald of the Sears corporation to fund the Rosenwald Fund, which helped build more than 5,000 schools for Black children across the South, providing infrastructure that existed nowhere else in Jim Crow states. Additionally, over its years, the Rosenwald Fund funded the very Black cultural infrastructure that helped fuel the civil rights movement, including movement builders such as W.E.B. Dubois, Langston Hughes, Marian Anderson, and Maya Angelou. By the time it closed in 1948, it had distributed more than $70 million toward Black civil rights.
This is an opportunity to capitalize on emergent strategies that capture opportunistic moments for long-arc organizing.
The Voter Education Project (VEP) from 1962–1964, which distributed nearly $1 million dollars for voter registration work in the South, was funded by three private foundations, the Stern Family Fund, the Taconic Foundation, and the Field Foundation. VEP registered more than one million voters in the South a year before the Voting Rights Act was even passed. VEP’s work is one of the clearest cases of foundation money directly enabling a movement’s field organizing at scale. Perhaps most famously, the Ford Foundation was a significant contributor and fueler to the civil rights movement, dramatically increasing its civil rights funding from 2.5 percent of its grantmaking in 1960 to 36.5 percent of its funding in the late 1960s. Ford was the primary investor to the NAACP and the National Urban League’s ability to expand and professionalize its operations, including funding litigation and policy advocacy beyond just the critical direct action of the civil rights movement. Many historians point to this funding as the moment professionally staffed civil rights became institutionalized and a model for more expansive replication across social justice movements.
Beyond the civil rights movement of the 1960s, philanthropy famously fueled the fight for marriage equality. Tim Gill, software entrepreneur, created the Gill Foundation in 1994 after Colorado’s Amendment 2 (later struck down by the US Supreme Court) to fund LGBTQ political activism. In the mid-2000s, Gill set an explicit strategic philanthropic goal to legalize same-sex marriage nationally within roughly a decade, using a mix of litigation funding, polling, data analytics, and field organizing, plus a political arm (Gill Action) that helped elect pro-equality lawmakers, and a donor-coaching network (OutGiving) that recruited other wealthy funders into the cause. Needless to say, the Gill Foundation was an undeniable philanthropic contributor to the legalization of same-sex marriage in this country, providing arguably the single best modern case study of institutional, professionalized philanthropy driving a specific civil rights outcome.
A history learned and a path forward
Now, in 2026, progressive philanthropy has more institutional power, infrastructure, and historical precedence than it did in 1969, and that history offers us a lesson that surrender is not the answer.
Given philanthropy’s long record of contributions to civil rights wins in this country, overcoming conservative attacks on progressive philanthropy is nothing new. The current attacks on philanthropy, that ultimately have fueled funder fear and retraction, resemble the previous attacks in which policy was used to stunt progress. For example, in the 1960s, following philanthropy’s significant contributions to voter registration for Black populations, Congress held 1969 hearings on private foundations that became, as one historian put it, a “public relations disaster” for organized philanthropy. The resulting Tax Reform Act of 1969 significantly limited private foundations from lobbying and funding voter registration drives and imposed new taxes and regulatory scrutiny.
Now, in 2026, progressive philanthropy has more institutional power, infrastructure, and historical precedence than it did in 1969, and that history offers us a lesson that surrender is not the answer. This should inspire our field.
I hold a lot of admiration for philanthropic organizers that are currently championing alternative resourcing methods outside of standard philanthropy—in fact, I engage in a lot of those strategies. But just as I believe in exploring new economic models for movement organizations, I also believe that we should reinforce what we currently have and rebuild what we have lost, as we expect to lose more sources of funding support in the future.
The United States turned 250 years old this year and we can still collectively work towards achieving our shared vision for justice. All the historic wins I’ve mentioned here prove that philanthropy can fuel significant wins and helping to shape the fabric of democracy. I genuinely believe that this period of funder retrenchment is not a foregone conclusion that our movement needs to accept as a new normal. Let’s organize and build together.