A floating silver kettle pours a stream of water, while simultaneously being filled by a stream of water.
Photo by Ralph Mayhew on Unsplash

Is philanthropy using all of its tools to drive social change? Program-related investments (PRIs) allow foundations to deploy loans, equity, and other repayable capital for charitable purposes, while providing regenerative capital. Yet only a small fraction of foundations use them.

Fewer than one percent of private foundations make PRIs in any given year.Consider a nonprofit that provides mental health services to underserved communities under a committed government contract. Reimbursement arrives only after the organization delivers its services, so it needs working capital to cover costs in the meantime. A foundation could fill the gap with a grant, but a low-interest loan could do the same and then return to the foundation to support additional charitable work. Such a loan is one example of a program-related investment (PRI), a tool that allows private foundations to deploy debt, equity, and other forms of repayable capital in service of charitable purpose, with mission taking priority over financial return.

Although federal tax law has formally recognized PRIs for more than half a century, they remain widely misunderstood. Many in philanthropy assume that PRIs demand specialized legal expertise, extensive documentation, and organizational restructuring beyond the reach of most foundations, and that assumption helps explain why fewer than one percent of private foundations make PRIs in any given year. The assumption is also, as our research found, largely wrong.

Our recent paper, published by Wharton Impact, Social Finance Institute, and the Center for High Impact Philanthropy, draws on interviews with professionals at 36 foundations that began making PRIs in the past decade. Our interviewees were split roughly evenly between those who found PRIs burdensome and those who found them relatively straightforward. The variation had little to do with foundation size or sophistication. Instead, it reflected choices that foundation teams made about three factors: the complexity of the deals they pursued, the capacity they drew on to execute those deals, and the congruity (or alignment) of their internal goals, processes, and culture.

Although federal tax law has formally recognized PRIs for more than half a century, they remain widely misunderstood.

In other words, PRIs are not inherently difficult, and much of the difficulty that foundations encounter stems from factors they can control. We return to those factors, and the practical steps recent adopters took to manage them, at the end of this article.

Why bother? Making the case for PRIs

Even if PRIs are more manageable than many assume, a fair question remains: If grants are familiar and PRIs are even modestly more involved, why not just stick with traditional grantmaking?

A principled answer begins with the purpose of private foundations. Foundations enjoy tax-exempt status because they are supposed to advance the public good. At minimum, that obligation means meeting IRS rules, especially the requirement to distribute a portion of assets each year for charitable purposes. But we argue that philanthropic responsibility goes beyond meeting a payout threshold. The exchange of public privileges for public purpose should entail thoughtful stewardship of charitable resources and a willingness to ask which tools best advance the foundation’s mission. A grant is often the right tool, but sometimes a PRI is. The point is to find the right capital and the right tool for the right challenge instead of defaulting to the same one regardless of the circumstances.

PRIs are not a universal tool, of course. They require a recipient with some plausible path to repayment, which generally makes them a poor fit for activities such as emergency relief, community organizing, or advocacy campaigns without revenue-generating components. But that limitation still leaves a considerable portion of philanthropy where repayment may be feasible, including healthcare nonprofits with earned revenue, affordable housing, and for-profit social enterprises.

Within that segment, let’s look at two situations where PRIs deserve serious consideration, one narrower but powerful where it applies and one that arises more frequently.

  1. When a PRI enables impact that a grant cannot. As an investment, a PRI establishes repayment terms or an ownership stake, and those features can strengthen an investee in ways a grant cannot. A loan creates a record of meeting repayment obligations, which the investee can later present to commercial lenders, whereas a grant leaves no repayment record to show. An equity investment brings the scrutiny and governance expectations that come with outside ownership. For example, when the Gates Foundation made an equity investment in bKash, a Bangladeshi mobile financial services provider, the investment’s terms prompted the company’s board to undertake a rigorous review of its governance, a step that one analysis noted “would be unusual in most grant agreements.” Because PRIs often sit alongside other investments in a deal, a foundation can take a first-loss or subordinate position that reduces risk for commercial investors who would otherwise stay away. For organizations whose long-term sustainability depends on accessing commercial capital, these differences matter because they may determine whether their work scales or stalls.
  1. When a PRI can achieve impact similar to that of a grant. Many organizations that receive grants also earn revenue that could support repayment, whether from service fees, rental income, product sales, or government contracts. For these organizations, the form of the capital may make little difference to what it accomplishes. The mental health nonprofit in our opening example, for instance, will deliver essentially the same services whether the foundation’s support arrives as a grant or a loan. When the quality of impact is comparable with either tool, the PRI offers a greater quantity of impact because of capital recycling. A foundation can deploy grant dollars only once, whereas a PRI’s capital returns to the foundation and can support another organization, and then another, and so on.

Regenerative capital as a tool for impact

Because the second situation described above arises more often, the capital recycling that drives it deserves a closer look, starting with the payout rules for private foundations. Like grants, PRIs count toward the minimum five percent of assets that a private foundation must distribute each year, but unlike grants, they can return capital. When a foundation recovers the capital it invested through a PRI, tax law adds the recovered funds to the foundation’s distributable amount, raising its payout requirement by the same sum. The returned dollars therefore go back to charitable use instead of remaining in the endowment. Any return beyond the original investment, such as interest, becomes part of the endowment, where it enlarges the asset base that determines future payouts.

When a PRI can achieve impact comparable to a grant, defaulting to the grant may leave future impact on the table.

Over time, the effect compounds. Our paper models three hypothetical foundations that each start with a $100 million endowment, earn seven percent annual returns, and pay out five percent a year. One makes only grants, while the other two direct 10 percent and 20 percent of their payouts, respectively, to five-year PRI loans at two percent interest (the model assumes that defaults claim 5 percent of PRI principal). All three foundations distribute nearly identical amounts for the first five years. Once the loans begin to mature, however, returned principal increases the PRI-making foundations’ distributable amounts year after year. By year 20, the foundation that directs a fifth of its payout to PRIs has deployed roughly $20 million more for charitable purposes than the grants-only foundation, starting from the same endowment size. Readers who want to test these dynamics against their own assumptions can use the Impact-First Investing Tool, a free resource from Social Finance Institute and the Rustandy Center at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business that compares a grants-only strategy with one that also includes impact-first investments.

The foundations in our model are hypothetical, but the opportunities to recycle capital are real and span many fields. An affordable housing project may need predevelopment financing before it secures permanent capital. A grant could move the project forward, but a PRI might achieve the same result while preserving capital for future housing projects. Or consider a workforce training program whose graduates often move into well-paying jobs but need help covering tuition up front. A grant removes the barrier outright, but in some cases, a low-cost loan with flexible repayment terms may remove much of the same barrier without undermining the intended outcome, while returning capital that the foundation can lend again. When a PRI can achieve impact comparable to a grant, defaulting to the grant may leave future impact on the table.

Repayment is not automatically a virtue, however. A PRI that burdens a fragile organization, shifts risk onto vulnerable people, or distorts program goals may accomplish less than a grant would. Capital recycling is a benefit only if the underlying investment produces meaningful impact and does not undermine the people or organizations it is meant to help. But when repayment does not compromise the intended outcome, recycling capital can become a significant advantage.

Foundations do not owe the public a PRI program, but they do owe the public a thoughtful account of how their philanthropic tactics serve their philanthropic strategy.

Weighing what giving expresses

We recognize that the argument for capital recycling presumes a particular view of foundation purpose, namely that foundations exist to produce as much impact per dollar as possible. That premise is widely held and easily defended, but it has never been the only one operative in philanthropy.

Some foundations place equal or greater weight on what giving expresses, whether trust in a recipient, solidarity with a community, or simple generosity toward those in need. For foundations with that orientation, asking whether a grant could have been a repayable investment can feel beside the point. A foundation team may reasonably decide that providing full scholarships to economically disadvantaged students expresses a value of fellowship and relationship-building that matters more than the number of additional students who could be reached by loans that recycle philanthropic capital. That decision is defensible, but it should be a choice arrived at through careful reflection and reasoned analysis.

Foundations do not owe the public a PRI program, but they do owe the public a thoughtful account of how their philanthropic tactics serve their philanthropic strategy. What distinguished the recent PRI adopters we studied was a willingness to ask the question seriously, match their approach to their existing strengths, and learn as they go.

Three steps toward successful PRI implementation

Putting that willingness into practice can begin with a simple habit. The next time a grant is on the table, foundation teams can ask two questions. Could a PRI accomplish something the grant cannot, such as positioning the investee to attract commercial capital? Or could it accomplish the same goal without undermining the recipient, while returning capital for the next opportunity? A yes to either suggests that a PRI deserves a closer look. For teams that decide to move forward, our paper offers a roadmap drawn from what recent PRI adopters have actually done, organized around three steps.

  1. Start with congruity. Before turning to execution, foundation teams should assess whether they have the internal alignment that PRIs require: a shared purpose for pursuing them, agreement on how much financial and regulatory risk to accept, processes sized to the needs of each deal, collaboration between program and finance staff, and committed leadership. Teams that skip the conversation about purpose may find strategic questions surfacing mid-transaction, as one interviewee discovered: “We realized we were getting the cart before the horse with a one-off deal.”
  2. Lean on external capacity. We found that most foundations are best served by relying on outside help at first. Peer networks offer templates and candid lessons at little or no cost; one interviewee estimated that peers “saved us a year’s worth of work.” Intermediaries such as community development financial institutions (CDFIs) can handle sourcing, underwriting, closing, and servicing, while external advisers provide targeted legal and financial expertise without the overhead of full-time staff. Foundations can build internal capacity as PRIs become more central to their strategy, and those with financially experienced program staff may reasonably start there.
  3. Rightsize complexity. Foundations making direct investments should start with straightforward structures, such as standard-term loans to established nonprofits with simple repayment schedules and basic reporting. First investments often go more smoothly with former grantees because the relationship and expectations are already in place. As teams gain experience, they can weigh whether the potential impact of a more complex deal justifies the added effort. Some opportunities warrant it, since the most effective PRIs often occur precisely where uncertain returns, long time horizons, and nascent markets keep traditional capital away.

Our full paper explores each step in more depth. We hope its findings help ensure that no foundation has to reinvent the path to exploring PRIs, and that more foundation teams consider adding PRIs to their portfolios.