Why Was Occupy Wall Street Being Occupy Sandy?

Print Share on LinkedIn More

Occupy Sandy

November 7, 2012; Source: Village Voice

“They forgot about us,” one resident told the Voice. “We’re like on some other planet.”

The stories about Occupy Wall Street participants declaring themselves Occupy Sandy disaster responders could be seen as proof of Occupy’s lack of focus, but according to the Village Voice, this is far from the case. In fact, Occupy was competing with no one and nothing as it mobilized to provide relief services and supplies to the hard hit areas of Red Hook and the Rockaways. FEMA made itself so scarce it created a vacuum into which all sorts of insults and injuries were added to the original storm damage.

The Voice article describes the scene in the Rockaways “where the storm surge rushed clear over the island, pushing beaches into homes and roadways, knocking out power, and filling every basement, storefront, and vehicle with saltwater.” On the Rockaway spit [?], 80 homes were destroyed by fire and high-rise apartment buildings sit dark. Residents tell the Voice that for some days following the hurricane, men were “knocking on apartment doors and announcing themselves as FEMA.” But according to a resident of Bay Towers, “Once you crack the door, they push in on you, come into your apartment, steal everything you’ve got.”

No one was doing an assessment of needs. Into this void walked the Occupy Sandy network, willing to provide some kind of response to institutional failure. Operative words…institutional failure.

The news that disaster response efforts are not always fair, especially to marginalized communities, is not new in the least. A network of dedicated volunteers may not have all the resources that should have been brought to bear to relieve the devastation that was wreaked on these communities but they did what they could in response to immediate need and highlighted institutional failure at the same time. A valuable service.

Some resident of areas in the far eastern reaches of Rockaway reported that the Occupy Sandy folk, working on their basic improvisational theme, were the only people to ask people exactly what they needed and if they knew of others who required immediate attention.

They were not completely alone.

According to the Village Voice, “Community centers opened kitchens and distributed batteries. New York’s Sikh Cultural Society set up an extensive relief station in Rockaway Beach near the foot of the Cross Bay Bridge, handing out food and blankets under a banner emblazoned with the serene face of Guru Nanak.”

Occupy Sandy, the article is quick to say, cannot and should not compete with the resources and tools of big, well funded relief efforts, but their efforts brought immediate comfort and safety, as well as media attention to the excruciating slowness of the response to people in communities that were among the hardest hit. –Ruth McCambridge

  • Aradia

    Instead of waiting for outsiders to come to the rescue, New Yorkers in Occupy organized relief efforts with their own neighbors. They already have resources in place where they do community outreach and feed the poor. Communities coming together for mutual aid in a time of need should be the model, not the exception. Hopefully, this isn’t just a fluke with Occupy and other Occupy groups around the country can serve their communities in their time of need as well.

  • Liz McLellan

    “cannot and should not”

    I am sorry but everything is not about competition. Occupy is a network, they WILL respond….like an immune system – and thank the Universe they did because the Red Cross – which collected 23 million is a day late and a dollar short…and FEMAs mandate apparently doesn’t cover dealing with poor people in any effective manner.

    What both Red Cross and FEMA need to do is get some researchers to study WHY Occupy has been INFINITELY more EFFECTIVE and LEARN everything they can from how the under 30 set does things.

    I am really sick of the arrogance of people in static 20th century organizations doing things the way they have always done..run mostly by people who spend more time on the cocktail circuit in Washington then on the front lines, .trying to make rules and recommendations about how to operate.

    Instead. Listen, learn and study the people who are getting it right. Have some humility before reality.

    When all is said and done they have an immense amount to learn from the efficacy of Occupy.

  • Liz McLellan

    I don’t think it is Occupy’s job to become the org that fills in for institutional failure. Their job is to pressure the system to reform – and they should be doing this endlessly.

    That they did step up is fantastic. I give them HIGH praise… but this IS the job of FEMA. This IS the job of the Red Cross…Occupy has a talent for networking and responding which is infinitely better than they do. They need to be brought in as paid consultants, they need to be studied in depth for their effectiveness and their model needs to be implemented…They should be recognized as leaders and their know how should be tapped.