
Farming 250, A Series with Civil Eats focuses on the question is being asked: What does America look like right now? In this new series, Farming 250, Civil Eats seeks to answer that question from the soil up. The newsroom is partnering with NPQ for the #WeTheCivic America 250 campaign.
This piece was originally published on Civil Eats and can be read here.
Walk through most grocery stores in the United States and you’ll see dozens of choices in an aisle, from cereals to meats and snacks. But a closer looks shows less options than first appear.
“If you look, it’s the same company. They just make us want to think we have choices,” said Joe Maxwell, president of Farm Action Fund. This “illusion of choice,” as Maxwell calls it, is a result of consolidation in the food and agriculture space.
This consolidation adds to other economic challenges for smaller farmers, and it can increase grocery prices for consumers. But how did this happen? The exact cause is a mix of policy choices, historic flashpoints, and pressures for farming operations to grow.
What Is Consolidation and Where Is It Happening?
Consolidation is the shift from smaller, often family-owned, operations to larger, corporate-owned enterprises. It represents a shift in the distribution of power from many small operations to a select few companies, creating near-monopolies that can undercut the competition. No corner of U.S. agriculture has been spared this process.
“Farmers are being squeezed from all directions,” said Duncan Orlander, a policy specialist at the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition. This includes seeds, pesticides, fertilizer, farm equipment, and processing, all now run by gigantic, often multinational companies.
A USDA study found that from 2018 to 2020, just two seed companies accounted for 72 percent of planted corn acres and 66 percent of soybean acres. Some seed companies have also merged with the chemical companies that produce pesticides and herbicides. Over time, seed companies can modify products to be resistant to certain insects or tolerant of certain herbicides.
For example, Bayer, makers of the herbicide Roundup, acquired Monsanto, which produced “Roundup ready” seeds that are resistant to that herbicide. The monopoly on these seed genetics often pressure farmers to buy both the seed and the chemicals from the same company—and there aren’t many options.
This “illusion of choice,” as Maxwell calls it, is a result of consolidation in the food and agriculture space.
The global seed and pesticide supply is dominated by four companies that keep tight control over these production areas, as well as the intellectual property for seed variants. The monopoly on seed genetics also puts pressure on farmers to buy.
Meanwhile, ranchers and other livestock producers face intense pressure from meatpacking consolidation. Poultry growers and ranchers have been advocating on Capitol Hill for years for greater protections against unfair practices by corporations.
Large companies have also diversified their products, expanding from grains or chicken to larger animal protein packers and more wide-reaching “food” brands.
Now, Tyson Foods, JBS, Cargill, and National Beef collectively make up about 85 percent of U.S. beef packing, 67 percent of the pork market, and 60 percent of chicken processing.
Oilseed and grain production are similarly consolidated, with a select five companies controlling different steps of the processing.
Corporate control of the processing end of agriculture production means that a select few players set the prices farmers get for their raw goods. It can also lead to higher prices at the store for consumers.
“There really isn’t a bright spot in agriculture or food,” Maxwell said. “There’s really not a sector that we have that isn’t heavily concentrated and driving up consumer prices through price gouging and then pushing down the prices to the farmers.”
How Did We Get Here?
Agricultural consolidation has become a mainstream concern recently because of fertilizer shortages and high beef prices. But the issue dates back to the early 1900s and the beginnings of industrialized farming.
Over the last century, several major events have accelerated consolidation, Orlander said. The first was the Dust Bowl, which hit in the 1930s, when more Americans were farming. Small-scale farmers abandoned their land, which was then purchased by larger operators and corporations.
Over the ensuing decades, advancements in equipment and technology allowed for greater efficiency, but it also raised farmers’ costs, causing them to take on debt to keep up.
Some of these innovations, like refrigeration and mechanized equipment, boosted yields. But higher yields led to overproduction of commodities—staple crops traded globally, primarily corn, soybeans, wheat, and rice—and lower prices, which in turn pushed some smaller farmers, already weakened by debt, out of business.
The trend was part of a greater ideology that emerged in the 1970s, pushing farmers to “go big or get out,” a phrase coined by Agriculture Secretary Earl Butz, who served in the Nixon and Ford administrations. Offered new technologies that increased productivity, commodity farmers were encouraged to plant “fencerow to fencerow” and to scale up production.
“A USDA study found that from 2018 to 2020, just two seed companies accounted for 72 percent of planted corn acres and 66 percent of soybean acres.”
This coincided with geopolitical maneuvers, like the Soviet Union’s covert purchase of a quarter of the U.S. wheat crop in 1972, which led to a collapse in U.S. grain reserves and a rise in global food prices. Many smaller farmers were unable to pay off debts, again relinquishing their land and giving corporations and larger farmers an opportunity to snap it up.
The 1996 Farm Bill, called the Freedom to Farm Act, signed by President Bill Clinton, also contributed to consolidation by reshaping the federal government’s involvement in farming.
It ended many of the farm safety-net systems that were established after the Great Depression by the Roosevelt administration’s New Deal. It eliminated acreage restrictions on crops that could be planted and generally decoupled farming decisions from government payments.
Given the prevailing low prices for commodities, farmers were pushed to overproduce in order to compete and stay afloat. These 1996 farm bill programs moved away from ensuring markets reflected a profitable margin and instead provided economic assistance when prices dropped, said Mike Stanz, vice president of advocacy at the National Farmers Union.
Trends toward consolidation have happened for other reasons, too. In pork production, for example, prices dropped significantly in the mid to late 1990s, scuttling many smaller hog operations. As a result, farms have grown larger, making it more difficult for smaller operations to re-enter the market and compete.
All of the factors driving consolidation were compounded by fluctuations in anti-trust and competition law.
Sign up for our free newsletters
Subscribe to NPQ's newsletters to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners.
The Political Evolution of Anti-Trust Law
The Packers and Stockyards Act of 1921 (P&S) was enacted in response to concerns about anticompetitive behavior among the top five meat packers at the time and the impact that was having on consumers and producers. The framework established by P&S enables the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the Department of Justice (DOJ) to prevent monopolistic practices.
During the 1970s and the Vietnam War, a political realignment increased the political power of corporations. Republicans at the time already favored big business. But a wave of young, college-age, affluent voters, bringing with them the big-business ideals of their parents, were also joining the Democratic party—and combining this with a desire to feed the world, Maxwell said.
These two ideologies formed a majority in American politics and set the stage for the levels of consolidation we’re seeing now, he added.
The 1980s, meanwhile, saw a relaxing of competition laws, in part due to shifting political alignments and the deregulatory push from the Reagan administration.
“More federal dollars alone are not the answer,” then-President Ronald Reagan said in a 1985 radio address, referring to challenges within the farm industry. “What’s needed is policy reform, including a long-term plan to get government out of farming and establish a more market-oriented farm policy.”
Former President Barack Obama campaigned on addressing consolidation within the meat industry and promised reforms once elected.
In 2010, the DOJ and USDA held workshops investigating consolidation in the livestock industry before releasing proposed Grain Inspectors, Packers and Stockyards Agency (GIPSA) rules. But the revised 2011 GIPSA rule was significantly stripped down after lobbying from the meat industry.
“As more and more Americans and, frankly, farmers around the world get to understand that they’re worse off because of concentrated power and monopolies, that gives us some hope that there can be change,” Mike Stanz, of the National Farmers Union, said.”
By the end of the Obama administration, only a few components of the GIPSA rule had advanced. Nearly all that remained were then eliminated under the first Trump administration, with a USDA that favored big agribusiness.
Then came the COVID-19 pandemic. Meatpacking plants were forced to slow or stop lines as the virus spread to workers. But with fewer Americans going out to eat, demand for grocery-store meat picked up.
As a result, meat was hard to come by and prices at the grocery store shot up. There were also consequences for cattle ranchers, who faced processing delays, lowered prices, and oversupply.
The situation highlighted the drawbacks of consolidation in the meat sector and the need for smaller, regional processing systems.
In seeking to address major changes from the Trump administration, including the weakening of Packers and Stockyards protections, the Biden administration sought to boost enforcement of anti-trust and anti-monopoly laws. President Joe Biden signed an executive order in 2021 that established a “whole-of-government” effort to promote competition, which included 72 specific actions.
The Biden USDA released a plan in 2022 to support fair and competitive markets for farmers. The DOJ and FTC also went after mergers, including blocking a merger between grocery giants Kroger and Albertsons. By the end of Biden’s tenure, the USDA had finalized three rules related to the Packers and Stockyards Act.
The first rule boosted the information chicken companies must disclose with farmers and protected farmers’ rights to discuss the terms of that contract with others. The second rule created enforceable definitions of discrimination, retaliation, and deception. The third and final rule in the set prohibited companies from using the “tournament system” to pay poultry growers.
The DOJ under Biden also obtained consent decrees in two P&S cases against poultry companies, resulting in payments to growers to make up for unfair compensation policies. Some of those companies also agreed to alter practices moving forward.
In January 2025, Donald Trump return to office and began undoing many Biden policies. This included some of the anti-monopoly efforts. In August that year, the Trump administration revoked the Biden executive order on competition. And in June 2026, it delayed the implementation of Biden’s “tournament system” rule.
But while the Trump administration has scaled back some efforts, the political momentum around consolidation and public awareness of the issue has not slowed down.
The Current Political Landscape and Possible Solutions
Conversations about consolidation in the fertilizer industry have been revitalized recently due to the war in Iran and the subsequent pressures on the fertilizer market. But for years, lawmakers on both sides of the political aisle have raised a wide range of issues around consolidation.
“As more and more Americans and, frankly, farmers around the world get to understand that they’re worse off because of concentrated power and monopolies, that gives us some hope that there can be change,” Mike Stanz, of the National Farmers Union, said.
Earlier this year, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-New York) introduced legislation that addressed consolidation and sought to break up monopolies, particularly in the meatpacking industry.
In March, Senators Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) and Tina Smith (D-Minnesota) introduced a bill to research consolidation in the livestock market.
In 2025, the Senate Judiciary Committee held a hearing focused on competition within the seed and fertilizer industries where farmers explained the impact that consolidation has on their livelihoods. Lawmakers on both sides seemed aware of and concerned by this historic problem.
“I recognize that consolidation can offer benefits, including cost efficiencies and technological adoption, which are critical for meeting global food demand,” said Noah Coppess, an Iowa farmer. “However, if the market becomes too constricted, it is ultimately the farmer who loses.”
Stanz said consolidation could become important through the midterm elections in November as Americans face high beef and grocery prices.
The consolidation challenge does not have a simple solution, however. Experts say that boosting enforcement under P&S will help, but a larger revamp of the agricultural system is also needed.
Duncan Orlander, of the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, said farmers are looking for a way out of the current system and into more sustainable practices. But these producers need better tools, safety nets, and markets to support them.
“As we see greater inequality throughout the economy and society,” Stanz said, “it’s time to go after that concentrated, consolidated market power and how it hurts farmers—and how it hurts everybody.”