PA Nonprofit Leaders Launch Increasingly Blunt Challenges to Gov’s Priorities

Print Share on LinkedIn More

February 16, 2016; Philadelphia Inquirer

Amid a state budget impasse, Pennsylvania nonprofit leaders and organizations are publicly demanding that the state’s politicians provide adequate funding for society’s most vulnerable people.

NPQ has reported on the ongoing state budget impasse in Pennsylvania and the efforts of nonprofit organizations to advocate for a humane end to the bickering.  In a recent development, more than 30 grantmakers have formed an advocacy coalition called PA People Count. The coalition encourages nonprofits and individuals to use social media to illustrate the community impact of their organizations. The coalition’s goals include getting the state’s commitment to “fully fund human services” and to develop “reforms to the state’s budget process so that Pennsylvania’s citizens, particularly its most vulnerable people, are never held hostage again by political battles.”

Three leaders of the effort wrote a joint opinion column for philly.com, the website for the city’s Inquirer and Daily News newspapers. Titled “No way to treat Pa. citizens,” the column uses blunt language to criticize the current impasse. Citing the state’s charities’ and foundations’ cumulative $2 billion annual grantmaking, the authors “refuse to let our investments be undermined by an endless cycle of poor fiscal management.”

Although the letter blames the state’s budgetary process, it clearly places blame on Democratic Governor Tom Wolf for signing an “inadequate 2015-16 budget…in which he vetoed $7 billion in spending after prolonged wrangling with the Republican-led legislature.” Unusually strong language from nonprofits when speaking of an individual politician, but illustrative of the boundaries of acceptable advocacy by a charity.

The letter, website, and coalition activities are not only unusual for their blunt criticism. It’s rare to see United Way chapters and community foundations such as the ones in the PA People Count Coalition take confrontational advocacy stances, especially in support of funding basic human needs. If anything, community foundations and United Way chapters are seen as part of the establishment, rather than challengers of it. Will this grantmaker advocacy take hold in other states, like Illinois, where budget stalemates are causing nonprofit programs to shut down for lack of funds?—Michael Wyland

  • Sharon Smith

    Sorry Mr. Wyland, but you misunderstood the message that the authors were sending and to whom it was addressed. It is incorrect to say that it “clearly places blame” on the Governor. The short-term budget that the Governor signed was an attempt to send at least some money to schools and service providers because the legislature refused to compromise in any way, shape, or form to the Governors proposed budget increases for education and to put in place desperately needed new funding sources such as a severance tax on natural gas drillers. Before the Governor took that desperate action, the Republican majority leadership and the Governor had come up with a working agreement filled with compromises. That version of the budget was torpedoed by the Tea Party inspired rank and file. Perhaps learning the background before pointing the finger of approbation at the Governor would have been helpful to your readers.